Friday 29 September 2023

Glamorgan v Derbyshire day four

Derbyshire 450-8 and 234-2 (Reece 119*, Came 57, du Plooy 38*)

Glamorgan 301-5d and 130-6 (Chappell 2-19, Thomson 2-31)

Match drawn

Before going on to the events of the final day, I think it is worthwhile that this post, at least initially, becomes one of appreciation for Luis Reece.

He passed a thousand runs for the summer today, and in the process finished it with the highest average of any player in the club's history who reached a thousand runs in a summer. Oh, and he became the first Derbyshire player to make seven successive scores in excess of 50 - those scores being 54*, 131, 201*, 77, 86, 139, 119*. That's 807 runs in seven innings at an average of 201. Bradman, you say? Nothing but an Australian Luis Reece...

Autumn has come too soon for Luis, who also became the first player EVER to score four centuries in a season against the same opposition. Back in the 1950s, Nottinghamshire bowlers could be heard offering Arnold Hamer money for his wicket when he had got fifty, such was record against them. It might be worthwhile Glamorgan considering something similar next year..

He is a special player and, with the very talented Harry Came, ensures that Derbyshire will go into 2024 with at least an excellent opening pair. They may turn out to be the best business done by Mickey Arthur this winter, even alongside the many other players who will be coming in for next season.

There was a lot of fuss today about the timing of Derbyshire's declaration. I wasn't listening all that closely to the commentary, but the Glamorgan correspondents seem to have felt that we should have bailed out earlier.

I disagree. I accept that we haven't won a championship game all season, but on a pitch where only 15 wickets had fallen in three days, setting 320 in 65/70 overs was only going to see one winner. Yes the ball was turning, but usually slowly and the boundary on one side was very short. 

In declaring 150 runs behind, Glamorgan seemed to want to have something set for them on the last day. Their idea of an appropriate total, however, seems to have differed considerably from that of Derbyshire. As we saw at Hove a few weeks ago, it is easier to control a four-day run chase, with the field set back, no restrictions and no issues with the balls bowled down the legside. So I can see both perspectives, but don't think we wanted to finish on a downer.

I would sooner go into the winter on the back of two encouraging draws, than by giving the final game away in a needless act of charity. What I would say though is that the cautious declaration doesn't really sit with our supposed mantra of playing aggressive cricket, risking defeat in going for a win. I get why they did it today, but perhaps the game plan needs to be revisited ahead of next season. 

For Derbyshire to push for promotion, risks have to be taken. We won't steamroller everybody (but somebody would be nice..) and there are times when the carrot needs well and truly dangled, a loss accepted as a consequence.

Derbyshire bowled well in the second innings, Zak Chappell reaching 50 wickets for the season thanks to a blinding catch by Matt Lamb, which might otherwise have gone through him, while Alex Thomson bowled some controlled off spin and Mitch Wagstaff seemed to baffle the home batters with his leggies. 

But it all ended in a somewhat predictable draw. Which might have happened anyway, even had Derbyshire set a less demanding challenge. 

We will never know, but the last afternoon of the season petered out as the shadows lengthened. Hands were shaken and goodbyes were said for another summer.

I will be back over the weekend at some point with my season review. 

It promises to be a long read...

16 comments:

  1. Phenomenal from Luis. I admit to being one who at the half stage of the season wondered whether we would see him next season.
    Can’t agree re the declaration. Far too cautious and probably explains whilst we have failed to win a game. We got 6 out with them being defensive, imagine what might have happened if they had a target to chase. It’s time our mindset changed ( we don’t have to be England) because 10 draws a season gets you no where. Let’s hope next season MA lives up to his rhetoric. Paul

    ReplyDelete
  2. I don't think that asking Glamorgan to score at less than six runs an over on a pitch that had favoured the batters was asking too much of them. Yes perhaps we could have declared a bit sooner but it's a difficult decision regarding exactly when to dangle the carrot and I don't blame du Plooy in the timing of the declaration. I teckon we could have won each of the last 3 Championship games with a little more luck and better weather. It's just a pity that our improved form at the end of the season didn't result in at least one victory. Looking forward to your season review PF.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Interesting paragraph on the Arthur piece on the official site:

    “We have refreshed the squad with seven new faces, which s quite a big turn over. We feel every one of them will help us and make us a better team, we’ll have two players for every position and that’s where you want to be as a squad. We’ve created depth.“

    With the part about the cover for every position and with three signings announced already (Lloyd, Amir and Brown), the new signings are likely to be:

    1. Wicketkeeper - A.Donald would be ideal or another batsman who can cover for Guest as per Arthur’s sentence about cover for all positions.
    2. Overseas - Allrounder?
    3. Spinner - S.Patel is the obvious link but if he isn’t playing red ball cricket, do we need another third spinner.
    4. Spinner? Who knows? Any guess on position? - Hoping this is a fourth new player in addition to a Wagstaff extension otherwise we only really have a squad of 18 players. Another incoming would make the squad 19 plus H.Moore with limited availability.

    Looking forward to your end of season reviews and hoping Reece can stay in form until April!! ;)

    Gareth

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Having listened to Mickey Arthur's interview on Derbyshire TV in which he talked about signing experienced winners a couple of weeks ago, Lloyd has already been signed and if Donald is also to be signed I personally am more than slightly overwhelmed by both of them Lloyd averages 30 and Donald averages 31 IMO both are just average County cricketers who have made one big score against Derbyshire, regarding Patel hasn't he made it clear he only wants to play white Ball cricket from now on, it will be interesting to see who the signings are

      Delete
    2. I think that you ask yourself if the players coming in are an improvement on those going out. IF we land Patel and Donald, on top of Lloyd, Brown and Amir, the answer is equivocally 'Yes'

      At the end of the day, you can only sign players you can afford, who want to come to Derbyshire. I maintain that the second overseas signing is crucial. I would prefer a spinner of genuine quality who can bat, but a seam bowler who stays fit would be a major improvement..

      Delete
  4. Irrespective of the timing of Derbyshire's declaration - and I felt it was too delayed - I'm surprised how much consultation there was between du Plooy and pavilion. You'd think there'd be an overnight conversation and then the captain would make the ultimate decision. This is one of the crucial arts of captaincy.

    I agree very much that the declaration hardly matches Derbyshire's supposed policy of playing aggressive cricket.
    I'd like Mickey Arthur to face a few questions about this and about the dead pitches prepared at Derby and elsewhere, all designed to drive away any other than the committed spectator and in complete contrast to the brave new world of England Test cricket.

    Thank you for another season of informed and judicious commentary. This and the outstanding streaming on the Derbyshire CCC website have made a pretty dismal season almost enjoyable for those of us who can get to few matches.



    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There are forums held throughout the season. At the last one, MA was asked about the pitches at Derby.

      He also talked about the type of attitudes he was trying to instill in the dressing room, and without naming anyone, he admitted there had been a fall out with one player. My understanding was that he was looking to create the sort of environment and professionalism one might expect at international level.....

      Delete
  5. Good to see you back Stone Rose and thank you for the links!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They seem to have disappeared, so here's the post:

      Thanks again Peakfan for your excellent coverage. I’ve been away but have accumulated a few things that fans may be interested in:

      “It has become a norm in recent years for players swapping clubs at the end of the season to bring their moves forward, but The Cricketer understands that Leus du Plooy insisted on seeing through the season at Derbyshire out of gratitude and loyalty rather than jump for Middlesex early, much as they could do with him now.” https://www.thecricketer.com/Topics/premiumfeatures/county_cricket_summer_sharing_season_has_been_saved_loan_spells.html

      “Gould also talked of guaranteeing on-going funding for "the network" of the counties. But those counties are going to have to sing for their supper. George Scrimshaw, for example, on Saturday became the first Derbyshire player (at the time of selection) to represent England since Dominic Cork more than two decades previously.
      “In that period, the club have (by the roughest of estimates) had about £50m worth of funding from the ECB. It seems reasonable to expect better from them or for them to accept money could be better resourced elsewhere.” https://www.thecricketer.com/Topics/premiumopinion/ecbs_equity_pledges_have_substance_game_must_avoid_repeat_inaction_after_1999_report.html

      Dominic Cork’s cap presentation speech to George Scrimshaw is also available on the englandcricket Instagram page (and probably the ECB accounts on other social media sites too). Definitely worth a listen/watch.

      Delete
  6. Thanks for all your very enjoyable posts Peakfan. Hope you’re able to keep up the good work. Steve B

    ReplyDelete
  7. The declaration should have come sooner for me. A draw did us no favours after a season which showcased our inability to force a positive result. I purchased a membership for me and my son (my first since 2004) knowing I would barely go partly inspired by MA's promise of a new mindset. I am yet to decide if I will renew.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks for your efforts PF. Simon

    ReplyDelete
  9. Glam fan here wishing to congratulate Reece on his performances - absolutely outstanding and made batting look very easy. With regards to Lloyd and Donald, I certainly wouldn’t get over excited if I were a Derby fan. To be brutally honest, were it not for fellow a North Walian connection with Maynard in handing him the captaincy, there wasn’t a place for him in our strongest line up. Have watched him have a very mediocre career to date and don’t anticipate any improvement on his career stats. As for Donald, well he’s a big gamble. Hasn’t commanded a place in any team over the last 10 years and sadly his performances fall way short of his ego. Here’s hoping that both Counties are able to rectify the significant problems associated with our respective squares over the winter, however I fear it will be more of the same next year. Cardiff and Derby (and from what I saw this year also Hove and Leicester) really are bowlers graveyards and make for the dullest cricket.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Another season ends with a whimper but I congratulate Luis Reece on an incredible acheivement, and Mitch Wagstaff on his successful entry into the 1st team - he is an exciting prospect. We await the list of new recruits with obvious anticipation - strength in depth is promised and will be needed - Yorkshire and Middlesex will prove very powerful cotenders for promotion next year.
    In the meantime, Peakfan, many thanks for your work on this blog for another season - very nuch appreciated.

    ReplyDelete
  11. A bit too late to start finding a bit of form Derbyshire, last April would've been nice. Good riddance to a horrible season and let's hope we can get a few quality signings in this winter now

    ReplyDelete

Please remember to add your name. Avoid personal comment at all times. Thanks!