Tuesday, 7 May 2013

One day prospects

We've played over a month of cricket by the time our first one-day match of the summer begins on Sunday. It hasn't been the best of starts, for reasons that are well documented, certainly on this blog.

Is this the summer when Derbyshire reverse recent fortunes and show themselves to be a better one-day than four-day side? If that were the case it would be long overdue, as we've seldom shown one-day form in anything other than a sporadic manner in recent years.

I would hope that Shivnarine Chanderpaul will do what he so often did for the West Indies and open in the shorter formats. That would at least give us a player who can pace the innings, always assuming that whatever combination of bowlers is chosen keeps the opposition within bounds.

For what it is worth, I think we might see an improved T20 this summer, especially if we can prevail on Martin Guptill to return for the competition. If he's keen to get home after a long tour, a batsman of similar power or talent is a necessity so we can take advantage of the power plays more than has previously been the case.

With plenty of slow bowlers to replicate the successful method of the better IPL sides, the Derbyshire team has the requisite skills to do well, though only if the players show their best form. I don't see us playing many seamers in the lucrative T20, where I think we will line up with something close to this as a first choice side:

Chanderpaul
Guptill
Hughes
Durston
Whiteley
Madsen
Johnson
Burgoyne
Groenewald
Knight
Turner

I'd like to see our two young spinners given a run in this competition and with Hughes and Durston to bowl spin too, we have plenty of bowling options. The batting has potential big guns up top, with the skipper in the engine room if it goes horribly wrong to work with the tail and produce a target.

There is an argument for Hughes to open with Chanderpaul, who could talk him through the tricky patches, but I'm a firm believer in having your best batsmen and fastest scorers at the top and with as long to bat as possible.

As for the Yorkshire Bank Pro 40, it is a competition in its death throes but I think we will see Derbyshire take it seriously unless they have early reverses, in which case it will become a blooding ground for young players.

My YB 40 side:

Hughes (C)
Chanderpaul
Madsen
Durston
Redfern
Whiteley
Hughes (A)
Johnson
Clare/Groenewald
Burgoyne/Knight
Turner

Much will depend on the fitness of the seam attack though. Having already lost Tony Palladino for several weeks, don't be surprised to see Ali Evans and Alex Hughes get YB 40 matches under their belt, especially if we need to wrap the remaining bowlers in cotton wool for the top tier four-day stuff.

Prospects? We have some good players and if we get on a roll an improved season is a possibility. Though if there's one thing that 47 summers of watching Derbyshire has taught me, it is to expect the unexpected.

But hey...we're playing in Edinburgh this year. I have a 'home' game to attend at the end of this month.

Please don't let it rain...

5 comments:

  1. Why pick whitely hes shocking, alex hughes is much better.

    Dave,

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well Dave, Alex is a very good cricketer but Ross has shown himself a real talent over the past couple of summers.
    I think that hitting a few balls in one-day games will help him and by the time the T20 comes he will be ready to clear the ropes again.
    Hughes is capable of forcing his way in though, no doubt about it. You'll have spotted him in by YB40 side?

    ReplyDelete
  3. It looks like Chesney Hughes may be unable to bowl at the moment. He did not bowl in Yorkshire's marathon innings yet Redfern did. Also did not bowl in the New Zealand game.



    Natwest 81

    ReplyDelete
  4. I,m afraid I have little confidence we will witness much of an improvement in our one day results from previous seasons. We have seriously neglected this format for far too long and our win ratio has been dreadful for long enough. I just don,t see it changing anytime soon. We have too many players who are not suited to this format and will never become effective members of a one day team. We will simply muddle through as usual and finish down amongst the dead men. There has to be a fundamental change in our thinking and planning before we can ever hope to compete with the better one day teams.

    ReplyDelete
  5. 2 4th places and one 3rd place in the past 3 years have been fairly respectable finishes in the limited overs format, and on our day we have shown we can beat anyone, wins over Sussex and Yorkshire being notable examples. But this season I think we will probably go backwards majorly due to the new fielding restrictions.
    Firstly, they majorly reward teams who keep wickets in hand for the end of their innings. Given that we struggle to do this when we are not looking to score quickly, I don't see this helping us one bit.
    Also, the reduction to 4 men outside the ring has made life harder for spinners, especially part time ones, so our reliance on people like Durston and Hughes could be problematic

    ReplyDelete

Please remember to add your name. Avoid personal comment at all times. Thanks!