Wednesday 10 April 2013

Warwickshire v Derbyshire day 1

On a day on which every county captain who won the toss asked the opposition to bat, Derbyshire cannot be entirely unhappy with their first day in the top tier.

I don't think many eastern betting syndicates would have lost money on that happening and it was equally expected that most of the sides struggled. We did too, but Karl Krikken will have been as heartened as the rest of us that the side continued to battle down the order.

At 105-2 we were looking good, but eight manic overs saw us reduced to 117-7. There have been many times when that would be a prelude to a sub-150 score. but this side is made of sterner stuff. 226 all out from there was good going and special mention has to be made of Tony Palladino (pictured), one of the most admirable of cricketers and men.

His batting last season came on in leaps and bounds and he put his new bat to good use with an excellent 68 full of powerful shots, well supported by the later batsmen. Credit too to Mark Turner, a much improved batsman who amply illustrated that this side doesn't really have a 'tail' - just later innings batsmen.

No one should be concerned. Had the toss gone the other way I suspect the result would have been similar. There are lessons to be learned from the careless loss of some mid-innings wickets, but that will have been discussed after the day ended.

The BBC's much vaunted launch of county coverage was, however, shockingly poor. I've had several comments and e mails today about the 'ineptitude' of Radio Derby's commentary and it really isn't good enough. I'm sorry, but if you don't know enough about your subject than to come out with some of the nonsense Charles Collins did today, you really should not be doing the job. To suggest that Palladino and Groenewald are only number elevens, as James (at the bottom of the previous post) says he did, is indicative of someone with minimal cricket knowledge.Indeed, it is insulting to two very good professionals

I followed the game on the BBC website at work, where the match scorecards failed to work all day, only the summary page, while the BBC cricket pages on TV text, or whatever they call it these days are an absolute disgrace. They don't display even half of the scorecard and if it wasn't so poor it would be laughable.

In conclusion? For Derbyshire there appear to be bright days ahead. The BBC? Looks like a relegation struggle. D minus, must do better...

9 comments:

  1. in the end it didn,t turn out nearly as bad as it might have done thanks to Palladino and Turner. A reasonable start was really undone by some poor batting more than any great threat from Warwickshire. At 109/2 we should have done better. If we can get amongst them tomorrow we might still come out with a lead,though my head says that is unlikely. Not the worst of days by any means but it should have been a much better one.

    ReplyDelete
  2. something has to be done about Collin's total ineptitude.He was unaware of which bowlers had taken or not taken wickets in a match he was being paid to report on. This, in addition to his ludicrous comments about Palladino and others.The constant patronising comments from the other commentators about him was/is embarassing and frankly, he is doing the club no favours at all. Can you get him replaced, Peakfan?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well anon, I am afraid I have no clout with BBC Derby! The best place to complain would be to the station itself if he really annoys you and other people. Judging from my mailbag yesterday that's a good few of you...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Did anyone find out why Clare didn't play?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I would think that with lengthening the batting Krikk wanted three bowlers he knew could keep going on a seam wicket. JC hasnt bowled as much as some pre season so I guess it was felt he was more of a gamble. Plus Turner's extra pace is very handy

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks - makes sense.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Tim, Chesterfield11 April 2013 at 14:06

    The commentary was made interesting only by the 'home' radio guys. It was puzzling that he appeared to have no idea who the Derbyshire players were. His discription of Palladino, Groenewald and Turner as 'three number elevens' or similar was frankly ludicrous.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great blog, can't wait for the ashes series to come around this year!

    ReplyDelete

Please remember to add your name. Avoid personal comment at all times. Thanks!