Monday, 8 October 2012

Well done to the Windies

Hats off to the West Indies for a fine win in the T20 World Cup. It was a tournament where no one seemed to give them real consideration as winners, despite the presence of several players who are star turns in the Indian Premier League.

Funnily enough, those names largely failed in the final, with Messrs Gayle, Bravo and Pollard doing little. The win came courtesy of one of the most improved players in the game, Marlon Samuels, a shrewd captain and underrated cricketer in Darren Sammy and one of the best T20 bowlers in the game, Sunil Narine.

Given the dominance of the West Indies in the 1970s and 80s with an attack of rare pace and hostility, there is considerable irony in the fact that they are now world champions over the shortest format because of a canny spin attack. Admittedly they were helped by wickets conducive to slow bowling, but it is no surprise that of the four semi-finalists three (include Pakistan) had attacks largely built around spin for the format.

It is accepted as the way to go in the modern game, always assuming that you have the bowlers to do it. I'm not sure that Badree is a world-beater, though he did a job, but Rampaul is a bowler of increasing variations and Narine is perhaps one of the best two or three T20 bowlers in the world. I'm less sure of his ability to get batsmen out when they don't have to go after him and his fledgling Test record is fairly ordinary, but Narine's long-levered off-spin creates panic in the T20. Last year's IPL saw him a standout and today he bowled beautifully. His ability to really rip an occasional ball leaves them wary to advance, while his variations are subtle and can only improve.

The likes of Samuels, Narine, Rampaul and the absent Dwayne Smith could and would all do a good job for counties in the English T20, but again, the likelihood of seeing them in 2013 is slim. Aside from the ICC Trophy, they have May series across formats against India and  July ones against Pakistan, so unless a player fell from favour, much as Wavell Hinds did a few years back, the chances of luring one to Derbyshire or anywhere else are slim.

Yet there are lessons to be learned in a competition where seam bowlers, irrespective of their pace, sit up to be hit with the slightest error in line or length. Just look what happened to Malinga today, bowling to a batsman in Samuels who was prepared to back himself in hitting through balls that were slightly overpitched. Spin is the way to success, making the batsmen force the issue and generate the power, often to their downfall. England Under-19s failed to recognise that in the recent World Cup, playing seam attacks who were meat and drink to good players while a talented spinner like Tom Knight sat twiddling his thumbs in the pavilion.

Next summer I think we will see a Derbyshire T20 side with two overseas batsmen, leaving the bowling in the hands of the domestic players. There's good reason to do so too, given that they were rarely collared this year. Such a side could - even assuming neither of the overseas players bowl - give you three, perhaps four spinners, with Whiteley as seam back up. There are any number of permutations, but given the increasing spin resources at Karl Krikken's disposal, it would be a surprise if we did not see them used increasingly in the one-day game next summer.

10 comments:

  1. As you may recall,Peakfan I advocated we sign two batsman for 20/20 last season.There is little point in signing bowlers who,s individual influence in these games is marginal.

    Two batsmen with a power game would do us far more good and if that,s the direction we are heading,then it,s the right one.

    I,ve felt for some time we have a tendency to under use our spin options. Not just in 20/20 but in general terms. There were a number of instances last season where Durston should have been bowled either much sooner or for much longer.

    We have also tended to over play the seam card in 20/20 which has done little to aid our cause. We need to learn that spin is nearly always the better option and opening with two spinners should be mandatory. We are well blessed with slow bowlers so we have little excuse not to use them. I hope we learn these lessons and put them into practice next season.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The flipside of your argument about having batsmen as overseas players is of course that if they get a jaffa or play a loose shot early on they're wasted to the game themselves. Even Guptill who was one of the top T20 run scorers in 2011 failed a considerable number of times and made little impact on matches.

    Also, given that we play our group games against sides in the north of the country on pitches that tend to seam rather than spin, it is rather a risk to pack your side with slow bowlers. If you were to play 6 batsmen, 3 of which were Whiteley, the back up seamer, Durston and Chesney Hughes, and Poynton and Wainwright at 7 and 8, could you afford to go in with either Knight or Burgoyne and only 2 specialist seamers?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't think that it is a given that we will have two overseas players in the T20 next year. After all, what have they done for us in the past? - Its many a year since we have even got past the group stage and the signings we have made, with genuine respect to those concerned, haven't generated revenue from crowds flocking to see them. The crowd pullers seem to steer clear of Derbyshire or are partially/not available.

    I would be happier if the second player's salary was put towards a permanent signing with the caveat that the new signing has a strong one-day game. The shorter version of the game is all that I get to see (after work) and it hasn't been fun in recent years.

    Craig

    ReplyDelete
  4. The point is Sam,batsmen have the potential to bat for 20 overs. Of course,they may be out first ball,but a bowler has four overs max and that,s him done.

    Our main problem in recent times and this applies to CB40 aswell,is we haven,t usually scored sufficient runs or have failed to score fast enough.

    The overseas player (who I hope is an opener) may fill one slot,which leaves space for a second player. Look at the history of T20 and spinners play a pivotal role,far more than seamers do. I,m not saying you can,t play a seamer or two,but it tends to be these type of bowlers who get carted.

    We must do better in all one day competitions,not least from a financial perspective and that will only be achieved if we improve as a batting unit.

    ReplyDelete
  5. To all those who think India didn't do well in this tournament.... India lost fewer matches than any other team in this tournament, and has the best win/loss ratio. But the Irony is they couldn't even qualify for the semi-final due to an unwritten understanding between Australia and Pakistan. It would have been a fitting final had India played West Indies in the final.

    ReplyDelete
  6. To be honest the month of June is becoming depressing year after year. I have given up on the 20/20, you cant keep failing year after year and have a positive outlook on it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Dave Houghton when interviewed by Kevin Howells during the Hampshire match was asked about David Wainwright and his impact since signing. His response was, as you would expect, to praise his efforts, influence and all round contribution.

    Interestingly he did suggest though that in his opinion the T20 affected Wainwright's rhythm, and when he reverted back to the 4 day game his bowling suffered slightly as a consequence. It was 'something they would have to look at for next season' he concluded.

    I agree spinners have a real impact at T20 and I felt that Knight could have been used more and maybe next season he will feature, possibly giving Wainwright less of a role if DH and KK think it would be of benefit.

    It was interesting to hear Atherton during the Hampshire game suggest that we would need to strengthen in the spin department for next season in division 1. Just proves how little he knows about us. The names Knight and Burgoyne obviously mean little to him. I very much doubt we will be signing any spinners during the close season Michael!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Just shows how much of a micky mouse competition 2020 is when a team like west indies win it.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Just watched Miller get hit in the face and go off injured for Yorkshire only to come back and win the game hitting 14 off 3 balls. Thats the sort of player we need for 20/20 a real power hitter.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The West Indies have done a great job in this years World T20 because in this years tournament not only their big gun Chris Gayle have delivered but all their boys have played well from the youngster Sunil Narine to Marlon Sameuls and their Captain everybody have delivered so this is the secret of their success.Congrats Windies.

    ReplyDelete

Please remember to add your name. Avoid personal comment at all times. Thanks!