Certainly there are some in the names below whose apparent availability is a surprise, but with Derbyshire in the market for players, a couple of these, maybe more, may hold considerable appeal. Nor should we discount potential signings of players who are still in contract, but want to be playing more senior cricket at this stage of their careers, or be given greater opportunity.
In highlighting the two names below I am not suggesting we are moving for them, nor indeed that they would come to Derbyshire. But nor should we discount the appeal of working with a coach of international renown, which we now have in Mickey Arthur. That either would enhance our squad is, I think, beyond dispute.
Danny Lamb
I am a big fan of the aggressive Lancashire all-rounder, a bustling right arm seamer and batsman. At 26 he should have played more than 19 first-class matches, but he always seems to take wickets and is a good enough batsman to have a century and three fifties to his name.
Economical in one-day cricket, might he be the latest from that county to move south, following Luis Reece, Ben Aitchison, Brooke Guest and Mattie McKiernan? Having Karl Krikken up there is no bad thing. There may well be a new deal for him, but is he happy to be merely a bit-part player?
Paul Walter
The giant (6'7) Essex all rounder is similar to Lamb. 27 years old, he has only played 28 first-class matches but averages over 36, while striking at over 130 in T20.
As a bowler, he hits the deck hard and from that height will always be a handful, even if only offering occasional overs. He might have hoped for more cricket with the retirement of Ryan ten Doeschate, but the arrival of Matt Critchley takes that place. If there is interest, Andre Nel, his former coach and fellow Protea will be able to give Mickey Arthur chapter and verse on his merits.
There are others, like Shane Snater at Essex, Ned Eckersley at Durham and Tom Bailey at Lancashire, but I find it hard to believe they will not be offered and sign new deals. All are fine players with proven track records - indeed Eckersley seems to have amassed much of his career tally against us.
Our need is for a younger, more affordable back up keeper, I think, with Brooke Guest one of those to shine in a poor 2021 and worthy of being first choice for now. There will be plenty around the circuit who would jump at the chance of fighting for the gloves.
There are a few spinners around and seemingly available, like Aron Nijjar, Jack Shutt and Amar Virdi, but their career records suggest little major improvement on Alex Thomson and Mattie McKiernan. Maybe greater opportunity could be the making of them all, but our two simply have to play some cricket to find that out and make worthwhile the award of two and one-year deals respectively. .
Were we to pick up either Lamb or Walter, one of our overseas roles could go to a spinner, or spin bowling all rounder. Sri Lanka have one or two, as do Pakistan and Mickey Arthur will know them all well from his previous roles.
That would perhaps leave the other role (for four day cricket) ideally going to a top order batsman.
Getting the right man in would make such a difference, as well as giving additional confidence to those whose struggles in 2021 were a puzzle after erstwhile glories.
I suspect, as most counties do, that four and one-day recruitment will differ in personnel. The congested International calendar largely makes it so and fewer players want to condemn themselves to a full English summer. So while we would likely be thrilled at Dimuth Karunaratne, the Sri Lankan Test skipper, for four - day cricket, we might fancy Wanindu Hasaranga for the T20. Who wouldn't, eh?!
As always, I welcome your thoughts and suggestions. I should point out I have erred on the side of affordability in the names above, so try to do the same if throwing a few names in the ring!
Hasaranga would be a fantastic coup, but as you say realistically he's only available for the Blast--he'd miss a lot of the Championship if he got a longer-term IPL deal, which I would have thought was almost certain. But if I was Arthur I'd be talking to him before I leave SL. (If you're trying to make use of MA's Sri Lankan address book, Kusal Perera for the Blast might also not be a bad shout).
ReplyDeleteIn addition to the things on Arthur's shopping list, I would have thought you'd need a new captain--certainly for red-ball and maybe white-ball too (I guess Hughes might be able to be white-ball captain). And given that you need a top order batter too (realistically, an opener I would have thought), I'd also be speaking now if not sooner to Karunaratne, who seems to be a highly thought-of captain in SL, comes across as a thinking cricketer and is in the test form of his life.
The experienced seamer that Arthur wants would have to be the second red-ball overseas player to my mind--there isn't anyone out there who fits the bill in county cricket. I'd keep Melton as a third registered overseas until he qualifies, so as to keep him, but not play him unless the overseas seamer is injured. You could do a lot worse than have another try at Sean Abbott (also one of the Sheffield Shield's most successful batters last season!)
So the keeper and the spinner that MA wants would have to come out of county cricket's unemployed or precariously employed. Nijjar looks like the best available option who's a realistic choice-- I can't believe that Surrey won't give Virdi a new deal, although he'd be a step up (no better than Thomson or McKiernan?--that can't be right, unless you're looking at one player to be an all-format spinner)
And a reserve keeper--well, good luck with that one! A quiet word with Middx to see if they'd part with Jack Davies, if he's approachable under the regs? The now-unattached Alex Milton? Tattersall on loan if things get dire?
In passing, from what I saw of Essex last summer, I'm not sure I'd put too much faith in Paul Walters's bowling. I'm not convinced he'd be remotely an improvement on your battery of medium-paced all-rounders. Danny Lamb would be better, but I can't see Lancs letting go of him--he was one of their key players last year.
Ian
Thanks Ian.
DeleteI just don't see us playing a specialist spinner that often, certainly not on Derby wickets as they have been, though MA might want different and recruit accordingly.
So a spinner who can get his share of runs might be an overseas choice. Any overseas batsman coming here gets a wake up call when the ball zips around, but Karunaratne is an experienced player and yes, I agree a new input is required as skipper, to let Billy focus on his batting.
As you say, Hughes could do that in T20 and RLODC, but isn't a fixture in 4 day cricket, or hasn't been.
I agree on Lamb, but few of their supporters saw them releasing Luis Reece. He needs game time and they have plenty of options. A long shot, but...
Walter? Yes, you may be right and I haven't seen him bowl lately, maybe a blip that a different coach could sort..
It will be interesting to see who comes in and we sure need a few!
I saw Lamb a few times last year - he's really improved and saved Lancashire a few times particularly in the one days. Would be surprised if they don't offer him a good deal.
ReplyDeleteAs it stands I think our CC first XI shapes up as:
ReplyDeleteGodleman (C)
Reece
Madsen
Du Plooy
Vacancy
Dal
Guest (WK)
McKiernan/Thomson/Marshall
Aitchison
Cohen/Melton
Conners
Came and Wood are batting reserves for the top order and Scrimshaw and Potts the same for our bowling with Hughes perhaps covering the middle order.
With Reece and Dal we are fine with 3 frontline pace bowlers and we have a few young and useful options.
At the moment we've three options in the spinner who bats a bit slot at 8, frankly that may be the easiest position to improve on with an overseas signing.
There is a clear vacancy in the top 5 for me and this needs to be a high quality overseas player. Someone who can bat 3 lets us drop Madsen down the order or equally an opener lets Reece drop down so either way gives us flexibility. Van Buuren is a really interesting shout, he's batted at 3 successfully for Glos and there was talk of him being imminently about to grt his British passport and qualify as non overseas, in addition he's a useful red ball bowler and fantastically economical in white ball.
So my shopping list would be:
Overseas opener who can play all formats. Janneman Malan would be ideal.
Van Buuren. Again strengthens our batting and spin bowling in all formats.
Overseas bowler. I'm not sure whether we want a spinner or seamer in this slot. It may depend on what sort of pitch we put out at home. Pretty happy with Conners and Aitchison to be fair so a really high quality spinner would be good and add value in white ball too .
Reserve keeper. Ideally someone who can keep Guest on his toes. A loan of Joe Cracknell from Middlesex would be good as they've a fair few keepers and he's one who can smack it in the Blast where Guest is perhaps more an accumulator.
Good comments as always mate!
ReplyDeleteWe mustn't forget that Reece is unlikely to be fit before June and I doubt will do too much bowling this year. I think Aitchison and Conners exciting, with Cohen, Melton, Potts and Dahl in support.
Our greater need is a quality spinner and a top order bat, as you say. Van Buuren would be excellent but his visa situation may be the issue for his county and us. IF we got Lamb or another domestic seamer it would be great.
Personally would like to see Wood at 5.He could be great against tiring bowlers and away from the new ball. His impact in T20 and RLODC was immediate and obvious, away from the new Dukes ball.
Hoping we should hear something this week...
Ah I'd forgotten how long Reece is out for!
DeleteThat would for me mean Wood comes in, either at 5 if the overseas opens (agree that might be a good position for him) or to open if they don't.
I would be surprised if Mickey Arthur's starting XI in RED ball cricket included Tom Wood.....
Delete