That have been a number of comments in recent days regarding what some people are referring to as Derbyshire's recruitment of experienced players 'seeking one last payday'.
Quite a few disagree and I am one of them.
It would be easy to go back to the period before World War Two and find any number of very experienced cricketers over the age of 40 in the first class game. Derbyshire signed Garnet Lee from Nottinghamshire and because of qualification requirements he did not make his debut until he was 38. Yet he played until he was 46 and probably produced the best form of his career in doing so, playing a major role in helping to develop the players who made up the 1936 championship-winning side.
After the war, counties filled their sides with players probably too old, because younger options were not there. So the Derbyshire ranks in 1946 included Albert Alderman, Denis Smith, George Pope and Bill Copson, all of them in their late 30s, while Tommy Mitchell would have played at the age of 44, had they been able to make it worth his while.
Moving on, the excellent Derbyshire side of the late 70s and early 80s was so good because of the recruitment of time-served professionals who aided in the development of younger tyros. Barry Wood and David Steele made their county debuts at 38, John Hampshire at 41. All were still very good cricketers and few were better than Eddie Barlow, 36 when he first played for the club. Ron Headley was very good in one-day matches at 35, Phil Sharpe was steady for two summers at 39, as well as being still the best slip fielder in the country.
Moving forward again, the England side that won the T20 World Cup final in 2022 had an average age of just over 33. The Australian side that recently won the World Cup averaged just under 32 years per player, with no player under the age of 29.
Next year's Derbyshire?
Here's a notional first choice T20 side (at present) of:
Reece, Came, Madsen, Donald, Lloyd, Whiteley, Patel, Guest, Chappell, Brown, Amir
Ignore the batting order, but the average age is again 33. The oldest players would be Madsen (40) Patel (38) and Whiteley (35). Could you name a younger player who would be a better option? All will be key to our chances and neither Madsen or Whiteley need hidden in the field, as once we had to hide the likes of Fred Trueman and Fred Rumsey, or more recently Ravi Rampaul or Imran Tahir.
As for Patel, his recurring T20 contracts around the globe suggest plenty of good judges feel he has plenty to offer. He might not be an athlete - he never has been - but there are few better limited over spinners in the game, he still hits a long ball and he has a safe pair of hands.
I firmly believe that Derbyshire's emerging young players will benefit from the input of such experience, while someone like Alex Thomson can tap into the expertise of Patel. Yusaf Bin Naeem will surely learn from working with the likes of Wayne Madsen and as for Harry Moore, might he not pick up a few things from Mohammad Amir?
I would like to think so.