Thirty-six teams were in this summer's Peakfan Blog League, the biggest number ever and I hope that you all enjoyed it.
I see my role as the facilitator, not just because I came third bottom, but because I seldom have time from mid-summer onwards to do anything with it. This is evidenced by my having thirteen available player transfers remaining at summer's end, as well as twenty captaincy switches...
Still, a lot of you have the skills of the game mastered and this year's overall winner was Paul Donkersley, who edged out Clive Whitmore by just 248 points. They came 123rd and 164th nationally, which was an excellent effort.
Perennial challenger Dean Doherty was third and sixth with two teams, while Paul was also fourth with his other team. David Aust, a past winner, came in fifth.
As they do every year, The Telegraph provide medals for various categories and I have been sent them. If the winners can mail me at peakfan36@yahoo.co.uk their address details, I can get these in the post.
Those winners are:
Overall winner - Paul Donkersley
Top run scorer - Clive Whitmore
Top wicket taker - Dean Doherty
Thank you to all of you for your involvement and I hope you are all involved again next year!
Saturday, 29 September 2018
End of season review
The 2018 season marked the end of the Kim Barnett era, who left mid-season yet can reflect on two summers in which more games were won than in any year since 2011.
There should have been more, too and a frustration for supporters, and challenge for new Head of Cricket Dave Houghton, is to turn more positions of dominance into victories. That said, there have been years where positions of dominance were few and far between, so the 'Barnett model', giving greater responsibility to the captain and senior group, can not be said to have failed.
Houghton can take this on and still allow his captain a degree of freedom. Where it fell down was in the leadership 'group'. Such a group is a laudable idea and some thrive upon it, but where ours fell down was that we had too many senior players who contributed far less than they should have, given their reputation and, one assumes, salary.
There are good cricketers in the Derbyshire squad, some of them very good indeed. The nucleus of Madsen, Godleman, Palladino, Reece, Hughes and Critchley is something that could be quite special, but fresh, better contributing blood is needed around them. The feeling hasn't gone away that we are a batsman light, though the above names, less Palladino, would likely make up five of the top six. The addition of such a player would afford greater balance and confidence that match-winning scores can be made, though there is still a question mark on the resourcing of such a signing for a county that hardly identifies with the word 'affluent'.
On a small staff with, bizarrely, three wicket-keepers, none made the role their own, despite opportunities. The side's need for a wicket-keeper who could make game-changing runs at number seven remains, though Harvey Hosein now looks the most likely bet. A lengthy run in the side would either confirm his talent or highlight frailties in his glove work which are still evident at times. Gary Wilson was a disappointment with the bat and is only a functional keeper, while Daryn Smit, excellent with the gloves, continued to struggle to score the requisite runs. Filling that role properly will be a challenge for 2019, a James Pipe or Luke Sutton the great need.
The bowling was better, but largely because of a golden summer for its oldest member. Tony Palladino took wickets when conditions helped and kept things quiet when they were less in his favour. A new two-year deal followed at the end of the summer, just reward for a player who is hugely respected both inside and outside the county.
Both Hardus Viljoen and Ravi Rampaul disappointed. While both bowled good spells in the Vitality Blast, in four-day cricket they were expensive, erratic and not especially penetrative. Viljoen could occasionally be fast and hostile, but too often lapsed into direction that was shockingly poor at this level. Rampaul's fitness came into question around the ground and, if both players are still at the club next year, a massive improvement is needed in both for us to progress further.
Duanne Olivier was the overseas player for the first half of the summer and proved a great success. Most supporters would be keen to see him return, even keener were he to take up a Kolpak deal. Yet his success will have been noticed elsewhere, his ability to move the ball both ways at good pace, as well as a skiddy bouncer that caused countless problems a prized asset. Watching him bowl, long arms generating unexpected 'whip', I was reminded of descriptions of Bill Copson. Duanne would not be upset with such comparisons with a county legend and his quiet, friendly persona would be welcomed back in the Derbyshire dressing room.
Lockie Ferguson did a sterling job in the T20 Blast, then was less successful, though whole-hearted, in the four-day game. In the short form, his combination of yorkers and short of a length bowling was a potent weapon, though more predictable from a batting perspective in the long form. His fitness enabled him to bowl long spells without his pace dropping though and he was a popular addition to the squad after arriving at short notice.
The spinners? Matt Critchley did better and a season's work in all formats of just short of a thousand runs and forty-four wickets was a good effort. Both his skill sets can improve still further and hopefully Houghton's coaching will turn a batsman who looks to have so much time into one who makes the big scores consistently. He had a golden week at Chesterfield and it is important that the club reward his talent and obvious potential with a deal that offers him medium term security.
Hamidullah Qadri had few opportunities but has plenty of time on his side and is not yet eighteen. His time will come and, like a few others, the appointment of the right bowling coach will see his game continue to develop. When he played he let no one down and his support bowling to Critchley at Chesterfield was perhaps overlooked at the time.
As for the batsmen, Madsen again passed a thousand runs and 1500 in all forms. His new four-year deal gives confidence for the future, as does the one signed by Billy Godleman. His one-day form was outstanding this year and his four-day form returned to the norm once he returned to his rightful place at the top of the order. Luis Reece was sorely missed for most of the summer and Alex Hughes came within sixty of his breakthrough 2017 tally, but at reduced average. His bowling came on dramatically, however and his value to the club could increase still further, as he turned 27 today and has his best years ahead.
Hughes had a tremendous Vitality Blast with the ball and the way in which Wahab Riaz mentored his bowling in the T20 should not be overlooked. The Pakistan international bowled with pace and nous at the top and tail of the innings, as well as playing some handy innings. His smiling demeanour made him a popular figure and many would be pleased to see him return in 2019.
My verdict on the summer? One of progress. Perhaps not as fast as some supporters would wish, but I like to base my expectations on reality, rather than fantasy. Pre-season I was one of few who saw them as better than bottom in the four-day game and also-rans in the short forms. We ended up mid-table across the board, which was about right. Yet three wins were there for the taking in the four-day game and had they done so would have finished in third place.
There is plenty to do in the winter. To allow for squad improvements, I wouldn't be surprised to see negotiated releases of some players from contracts, because we need much more from those who are the best rewarded. We need a batsman of quality and one, perhaps two bowlers who can be relied upon, but we are moving in the right direction.
The budget is the key factor and such additions do not come cheap. Thus the ongoing and stated development of our own talent is crucial and that will take time.
There were plenty of golden moments to look back on over the winter, however. That has to be worth something and sets us up for a hopefully exciting 2019.
Your thoughts?
There should have been more, too and a frustration for supporters, and challenge for new Head of Cricket Dave Houghton, is to turn more positions of dominance into victories. That said, there have been years where positions of dominance were few and far between, so the 'Barnett model', giving greater responsibility to the captain and senior group, can not be said to have failed.
Houghton can take this on and still allow his captain a degree of freedom. Where it fell down was in the leadership 'group'. Such a group is a laudable idea and some thrive upon it, but where ours fell down was that we had too many senior players who contributed far less than they should have, given their reputation and, one assumes, salary.
There are good cricketers in the Derbyshire squad, some of them very good indeed. The nucleus of Madsen, Godleman, Palladino, Reece, Hughes and Critchley is something that could be quite special, but fresh, better contributing blood is needed around them. The feeling hasn't gone away that we are a batsman light, though the above names, less Palladino, would likely make up five of the top six. The addition of such a player would afford greater balance and confidence that match-winning scores can be made, though there is still a question mark on the resourcing of such a signing for a county that hardly identifies with the word 'affluent'.
On a small staff with, bizarrely, three wicket-keepers, none made the role their own, despite opportunities. The side's need for a wicket-keeper who could make game-changing runs at number seven remains, though Harvey Hosein now looks the most likely bet. A lengthy run in the side would either confirm his talent or highlight frailties in his glove work which are still evident at times. Gary Wilson was a disappointment with the bat and is only a functional keeper, while Daryn Smit, excellent with the gloves, continued to struggle to score the requisite runs. Filling that role properly will be a challenge for 2019, a James Pipe or Luke Sutton the great need.
The bowling was better, but largely because of a golden summer for its oldest member. Tony Palladino took wickets when conditions helped and kept things quiet when they were less in his favour. A new two-year deal followed at the end of the summer, just reward for a player who is hugely respected both inside and outside the county.
Both Hardus Viljoen and Ravi Rampaul disappointed. While both bowled good spells in the Vitality Blast, in four-day cricket they were expensive, erratic and not especially penetrative. Viljoen could occasionally be fast and hostile, but too often lapsed into direction that was shockingly poor at this level. Rampaul's fitness came into question around the ground and, if both players are still at the club next year, a massive improvement is needed in both for us to progress further.
Duanne Olivier was the overseas player for the first half of the summer and proved a great success. Most supporters would be keen to see him return, even keener were he to take up a Kolpak deal. Yet his success will have been noticed elsewhere, his ability to move the ball both ways at good pace, as well as a skiddy bouncer that caused countless problems a prized asset. Watching him bowl, long arms generating unexpected 'whip', I was reminded of descriptions of Bill Copson. Duanne would not be upset with such comparisons with a county legend and his quiet, friendly persona would be welcomed back in the Derbyshire dressing room.
Lockie Ferguson did a sterling job in the T20 Blast, then was less successful, though whole-hearted, in the four-day game. In the short form, his combination of yorkers and short of a length bowling was a potent weapon, though more predictable from a batting perspective in the long form. His fitness enabled him to bowl long spells without his pace dropping though and he was a popular addition to the squad after arriving at short notice.
The spinners? Matt Critchley did better and a season's work in all formats of just short of a thousand runs and forty-four wickets was a good effort. Both his skill sets can improve still further and hopefully Houghton's coaching will turn a batsman who looks to have so much time into one who makes the big scores consistently. He had a golden week at Chesterfield and it is important that the club reward his talent and obvious potential with a deal that offers him medium term security.
Hamidullah Qadri had few opportunities but has plenty of time on his side and is not yet eighteen. His time will come and, like a few others, the appointment of the right bowling coach will see his game continue to develop. When he played he let no one down and his support bowling to Critchley at Chesterfield was perhaps overlooked at the time.
As for the batsmen, Madsen again passed a thousand runs and 1500 in all forms. His new four-year deal gives confidence for the future, as does the one signed by Billy Godleman. His one-day form was outstanding this year and his four-day form returned to the norm once he returned to his rightful place at the top of the order. Luis Reece was sorely missed for most of the summer and Alex Hughes came within sixty of his breakthrough 2017 tally, but at reduced average. His bowling came on dramatically, however and his value to the club could increase still further, as he turned 27 today and has his best years ahead.
Hughes had a tremendous Vitality Blast with the ball and the way in which Wahab Riaz mentored his bowling in the T20 should not be overlooked. The Pakistan international bowled with pace and nous at the top and tail of the innings, as well as playing some handy innings. His smiling demeanour made him a popular figure and many would be pleased to see him return in 2019.
My verdict on the summer? One of progress. Perhaps not as fast as some supporters would wish, but I like to base my expectations on reality, rather than fantasy. Pre-season I was one of few who saw them as better than bottom in the four-day game and also-rans in the short forms. We ended up mid-table across the board, which was about right. Yet three wins were there for the taking in the four-day game and had they done so would have finished in third place.
There is plenty to do in the winter. To allow for squad improvements, I wouldn't be surprised to see negotiated releases of some players from contracts, because we need much more from those who are the best rewarded. We need a batsman of quality and one, perhaps two bowlers who can be relied upon, but we are moving in the right direction.
The budget is the key factor and such additions do not come cheap. Thus the ongoing and stated development of our own talent is crucial and that will take time.
There were plenty of golden moments to look back on over the winter, however. That has to be worth something and sets us up for a hopefully exciting 2019.
Your thoughts?
Friday, 28 September 2018
Contracts keep coming at Derbyshire
Safely returned to the bosom of my family near Glasgow today, I have a little time to offer my thoughts on the new contracts for Anuj Dal, Matt McKiernan and Luis Reece and the departure of Will Davis.
Departures are always sad and especially when it is a player who at one point looked to be something quite special. Will Davis burst on to the scene, bowled some spells of serious pace and looked to be a bowler with a big future. To be fair, so did Tom Taylor, Ben Cotton and Greg Cork in their time and questions need to be asked as to why our academy bowlers are not kicking on such as, for example, the ones at Worcestershire or Leicestershire. Whatever Dave Houghton does when he comes into post, he needs to get a handle on why academy progression is really an oxymoron.
For some young players, premature departure from clubs is down to some combination of attitude, indiscipline, poor fitness, limited skill set or lack of opportunity. No one can deny that Will Davis has a bucket load of talent, but now, after becoming the latest Derbyshire player to end up on the conveyor belt to Leicester, he needs to find his own answers to why it didn't work out at Derbyshire.
The bottom line is that he didn't play enough cricket. There are similarities with Alan Ward, also slight in physique and who also headed down to Leicester with less success than he had at his home county. Last winter Davis had his own personalised fitness programme, apparently looked really good in the nets, but probably played less cricket than in previous summers, when to be fair he didn't play a lot either.
He is unlucky, because at 22 he is nowhere near developed physically, but perhaps the mental side of fast bowling needs addressed too. Ask any quick bowler worth his salt and they will tell you they are rarely pain-free, but you have to learn to handle it until, perhaps in your mid-twenties, your body is better able to cope. Both Wahab Riaz and Lockie Ferguson said as much before a T20 game this summer and it is just a shame that our finances do not allow more time for youthful prodigies. If Davis can overcome his physical frailties, he could still be a very good bowler. By the same token, I don't blame Derbyshire for releasing him, because there is an expectation, after several summers on the staff, that a player should be better able to play cricket.
Will Davis wasn't and while it is a shame to see him go, I don't blame the club for releasing him to better use the money elsewhere. I wish him well at Leicestershire and will follow his progress with interest.
A direct beneficiary of his departure is likely to be Matt McKiernan, as well as Anuj Dal, I would be surprised - and very impressed - if our financial situation as it stands allows for major recruitment this winter, but both of these players did well in limited opportunities. Both are all rounders, though Dal hardly bowled in his first team opportunities this year. I could have understood the decision whichever way it had gone, because he didn't make the most of his opportunities in weight of runs. But enough has been seen in his fast hands and feet to think that Dave Houghton may polish up a gem over the winter.
Dal can defend and attack well. What he needs to do now is build on composed twenties and thirties and turn them into big scores. Was there, or will there be consideration of Chesney Hughes, who scored a lot more runs in the second team than him? Maybe his boat has sailed, but Anuj is young enough to develop still further. By the same token, perhaps at 27 Chesney is coming to his peak...
McKiernan is a good cricketer and as a leg-spinning all rounder will give us another option on turning tracks next year. Earlier in the summer I watched a Glamorgan player clump him into the vegetation at Belper, before perishing two balls later, trying to repeat the shot from a similar, but more flighted delivery. He bowls a good length and turns his googly impressively, while his batting ability will do him no harm. Maybe he is also a plan B, just in case Matt Critchley is tempted elsewhere, but I hope Critch realises that his game can come on much more playing regular cricket at Derbyshire than being a more peripheral figure at a 'bigger' county.
As for Luis Reece, a new deal was a no brainer. He is a class act and was sorely missed for the majority of the summer. In adding him to those on extended deals, the club has secured one of the country's best all-rounders.
I expect to see him cement that title in the coming years and thoroughly enjoy watching him, whether batting or bowling. He makes things happen and, crucially, goes about his game with a smile on his face.
The lot of a professional cricketer is one that many aspire to, but few have the skills to achieve. Reece has those skills in spades and looks like he enjoys every single minute.
There's something for others around the country to aspire to, right there.
Departures are always sad and especially when it is a player who at one point looked to be something quite special. Will Davis burst on to the scene, bowled some spells of serious pace and looked to be a bowler with a big future. To be fair, so did Tom Taylor, Ben Cotton and Greg Cork in their time and questions need to be asked as to why our academy bowlers are not kicking on such as, for example, the ones at Worcestershire or Leicestershire. Whatever Dave Houghton does when he comes into post, he needs to get a handle on why academy progression is really an oxymoron.
For some young players, premature departure from clubs is down to some combination of attitude, indiscipline, poor fitness, limited skill set or lack of opportunity. No one can deny that Will Davis has a bucket load of talent, but now, after becoming the latest Derbyshire player to end up on the conveyor belt to Leicester, he needs to find his own answers to why it didn't work out at Derbyshire.
The bottom line is that he didn't play enough cricket. There are similarities with Alan Ward, also slight in physique and who also headed down to Leicester with less success than he had at his home county. Last winter Davis had his own personalised fitness programme, apparently looked really good in the nets, but probably played less cricket than in previous summers, when to be fair he didn't play a lot either.
He is unlucky, because at 22 he is nowhere near developed physically, but perhaps the mental side of fast bowling needs addressed too. Ask any quick bowler worth his salt and they will tell you they are rarely pain-free, but you have to learn to handle it until, perhaps in your mid-twenties, your body is better able to cope. Both Wahab Riaz and Lockie Ferguson said as much before a T20 game this summer and it is just a shame that our finances do not allow more time for youthful prodigies. If Davis can overcome his physical frailties, he could still be a very good bowler. By the same token, I don't blame Derbyshire for releasing him, because there is an expectation, after several summers on the staff, that a player should be better able to play cricket.
Will Davis wasn't and while it is a shame to see him go, I don't blame the club for releasing him to better use the money elsewhere. I wish him well at Leicestershire and will follow his progress with interest.
A direct beneficiary of his departure is likely to be Matt McKiernan, as well as Anuj Dal, I would be surprised - and very impressed - if our financial situation as it stands allows for major recruitment this winter, but both of these players did well in limited opportunities. Both are all rounders, though Dal hardly bowled in his first team opportunities this year. I could have understood the decision whichever way it had gone, because he didn't make the most of his opportunities in weight of runs. But enough has been seen in his fast hands and feet to think that Dave Houghton may polish up a gem over the winter.
Dal can defend and attack well. What he needs to do now is build on composed twenties and thirties and turn them into big scores. Was there, or will there be consideration of Chesney Hughes, who scored a lot more runs in the second team than him? Maybe his boat has sailed, but Anuj is young enough to develop still further. By the same token, perhaps at 27 Chesney is coming to his peak...
McKiernan is a good cricketer and as a leg-spinning all rounder will give us another option on turning tracks next year. Earlier in the summer I watched a Glamorgan player clump him into the vegetation at Belper, before perishing two balls later, trying to repeat the shot from a similar, but more flighted delivery. He bowls a good length and turns his googly impressively, while his batting ability will do him no harm. Maybe he is also a plan B, just in case Matt Critchley is tempted elsewhere, but I hope Critch realises that his game can come on much more playing regular cricket at Derbyshire than being a more peripheral figure at a 'bigger' county.
As for Luis Reece, a new deal was a no brainer. He is a class act and was sorely missed for the majority of the summer. In adding him to those on extended deals, the club has secured one of the country's best all-rounders.
I expect to see him cement that title in the coming years and thoroughly enjoy watching him, whether batting or bowling. He makes things happen and, crucially, goes about his game with a smile on his face.
The lot of a professional cricketer is one that many aspire to, but few have the skills to achieve. Reece has those skills in spades and looks like he enjoys every single minute.
There's something for others around the country to aspire to, right there.
Thursday, 27 September 2018
Reece extends contract as Davis leaves
Yesterday's news that Luis Reece has signed an improved and extended contract that sees him remain at the club until the end of 2021 is welcome and very exciting.
Today's news that Will Davis is leaving the club is sad, but tinged with an inevitability that doesn't make it such a surprise.
Both are worthy of more time than I have at present, when I am at my parents with things to do.
I travel home tomorrow and will give both the time and space that they deserve over the course of the weekend.
Today's news that Will Davis is leaving the club is sad, but tinged with an inevitability that doesn't make it such a surprise.
Both are worthy of more time than I have at present, when I am at my parents with things to do.
I travel home tomorrow and will give both the time and space that they deserve over the course of the weekend.
Wednesday, 26 September 2018
Derbyshire v Gloucestershire day 3
Derbyshire 184 and 157
Gloucestershire 163 and 179-8 (Howell 58, Ferguson 4-59)
Gloucestershire won by two wickets
The final day of the county cricket season, as day three was always going to be after the cascade of wickets on day one, dawned sunny and cold. On my approach to the ground, a lengthy queue on Sir Frank Whittle Road suggested a large crowd to witness the closing sessions of cricket for another summer.
Alas, 'twas not so but a reasonable smattering of hardy souls were scattered around the ground in a mixture of summer and (more commonly) winter jackets, most of them hoping to see a home win to rival that of Derby County at Old Trafford last night.
Yet when Tony Palladino and Lockie Ferguson opened the bowling this morning, there appeared to be less movement than yesterday. The work of the roller, to some extent, plus the wicket having dried out, but the bowlers didn't help themselves with too much loose bowling, overpitched and on the batsman's legs.
Both Hammond and Howell batted well, as you had to do to stay in on this wicket. Palladino looked the most likely to get the breakthrough and eventually did, but an earlier opportunity to remove Hammond than was eventually taken was put down. Ferguson put down a hard and fast chance that was straight at him, Palladino's frustration both visible and audible.
At lunch the result looked like going the way of the visitors and afterwards they progressed towards victory with a haste somewhat unseemly in the context of the match. Benny Howell continued to play some splendid shots and the fastest balls that Ferguson could muster came to naught.
Hosein moved up to the stumps for Palladino, in an attempt to disturb the batting equilibrium, but nothing happened until the belated introduction of Matt Critchley to the attack. Howell's attempt to hit him into the middle distance resulted in an outside edge, well caught by Hughes at backward point. Charlesworth was then leg before and Ferguson, bowling at great pace, removed Higgins and Taylor, the latter brilliantly caught by the diving Godleman.
Ten were needed from the last two wickets and Critchley was kept on to bowl to Miles. A long hop went down to fine leg for four and then a powerful straight drive went through his outstretched hands for the winning boundary.
It was a fine game of cricket, played on the best kind of track you could wish for. Batsmen could make runs with sound technique and due diligence, while bowlers felt that they could get something out of it by bending their backs.
At the end of it all, another twenty runs might have made a difference. Those first innings extras were unnecessarily generous and came back to bite us today.
It was the third game this summer - after the away games at Durham and Glamorgan - where we had eased ourselves into a position of strength, only to blow it when it mattered.
Something to work on over the winter.
I'll be back with an end of season report over the weekend.
Gloucestershire 163 and 179-8 (Howell 58, Ferguson 4-59)
Gloucestershire won by two wickets
The final day of the county cricket season, as day three was always going to be after the cascade of wickets on day one, dawned sunny and cold. On my approach to the ground, a lengthy queue on Sir Frank Whittle Road suggested a large crowd to witness the closing sessions of cricket for another summer.
Alas, 'twas not so but a reasonable smattering of hardy souls were scattered around the ground in a mixture of summer and (more commonly) winter jackets, most of them hoping to see a home win to rival that of Derby County at Old Trafford last night.
Yet when Tony Palladino and Lockie Ferguson opened the bowling this morning, there appeared to be less movement than yesterday. The work of the roller, to some extent, plus the wicket having dried out, but the bowlers didn't help themselves with too much loose bowling, overpitched and on the batsman's legs.
Both Hammond and Howell batted well, as you had to do to stay in on this wicket. Palladino looked the most likely to get the breakthrough and eventually did, but an earlier opportunity to remove Hammond than was eventually taken was put down. Ferguson put down a hard and fast chance that was straight at him, Palladino's frustration both visible and audible.
At lunch the result looked like going the way of the visitors and afterwards they progressed towards victory with a haste somewhat unseemly in the context of the match. Benny Howell continued to play some splendid shots and the fastest balls that Ferguson could muster came to naught.
Hosein moved up to the stumps for Palladino, in an attempt to disturb the batting equilibrium, but nothing happened until the belated introduction of Matt Critchley to the attack. Howell's attempt to hit him into the middle distance resulted in an outside edge, well caught by Hughes at backward point. Charlesworth was then leg before and Ferguson, bowling at great pace, removed Higgins and Taylor, the latter brilliantly caught by the diving Godleman.
Ten were needed from the last two wickets and Critchley was kept on to bowl to Miles. A long hop went down to fine leg for four and then a powerful straight drive went through his outstretched hands for the winning boundary.
It was a fine game of cricket, played on the best kind of track you could wish for. Batsmen could make runs with sound technique and due diligence, while bowlers felt that they could get something out of it by bending their backs.
At the end of it all, another twenty runs might have made a difference. Those first innings extras were unnecessarily generous and came back to bite us today.
It was the third game this summer - after the away games at Durham and Glamorgan - where we had eased ourselves into a position of strength, only to blow it when it mattered.
Something to work on over the winter.
I'll be back with an end of season report over the weekend.
Tuesday, 25 September 2018
Derbyshire v Gloucestershire day 2
A 5.30am departure from home in Glasgow got me to the 3aaa County Ground in time to hear the cheers as Lockie Ferguson removed overnight batsman Drissell with a trademark fast and straight delivery this morning.
Thereafter it was largely the Luis Reece show again, with the all-rounder completing figures of 7-20, the most economical for a seven wicket haul for the county since the legendary, nay infamous, Bill Bestwick at Burton on Trent in 1920. It is fair to say that the two are somewhat diametrically opposed as personalities and Luis is a considerably better batsman than Bill. Mind you, Bill took 1457 wickets for the county, so Luis has some way to go with a ball in his hand...
Today he bowled another spell of immaculate line and length, the batsmen seemingly unaware how to combat his left arm swing. When Lockie Ferguson held on to catch at mid wicket to take the seventh, he was instantly surrounded by his team mates, who had been commendably upbeat and chipper all morning. It was a superb spell of controlled swing bowling, yet in marked contrast to two dreadful overs bowled by Hardus Viljoen before he was withdrawn from the attack. In a low-scoring game, 34 extras conceded, sixteen byes and ten wides, is unacceptable at this level and I attribute little blame to the wicket-keeper. One ball that went to the fence would have challenged a wide leg slip to take and it is so frustrating to see. Ironically, Viljoen produced a beauty with his final ball to dismiss Higgins, there being little that the batsman could do before the catch was pouched expertly at slip by Wayne Madsen.
A lead of 21 could have been more with less profligate bowling by the fast bowlers and it seemed to me that our best chance of winning this in the final innings will be for the bulk of the bowling to be done by Messrs Palladino, Reece and Hughes. Runs will be at a premium and we can ill afford to give away freebies as we did first time around.
The batting procession continued as our second innings began, the skipper's final knock of the summer lasting just three balls before being given leg before. Madsen and Reece saw it through to lunch but both went soon afterwards, at 32-3 the home side in danger of giving away their fine work earlier.
The Gloucestershire bowlers did well again. I particularly liked the look of Ryan Higgins, who bristled aggression though not really having the pace for it. He nipped it around as he has all season, as did David Payne, a bowler I have admired for some time and the ball fizzed past the bat and rapped the pad with uneasy frequency.
Yet Alex Hughes and Tom Lace showed commendable fortitude and no little skill in adding a painstaking partnership. It was proper, attritional, fascinating county cricket. Alex always looks good in such situations and sells his wicket dearly, while my first 'proper' sighting of Lace was enjoyable. He showed sound technique against a moving ball and got his head down again after a nasty blow on the arm from one that lifted from a length. Probably not what he wanted to be on the end of, but for the watching Derbyshire bowlers, something that may have brought a smile to their faces.
Of course, on such a wicket danger lurks in every delivery and Lace fell leg before to Howell for a hard-earned seventeen. It was nothing impressive in the score book, but worth more in the context of the game. At 66-4, there was more rebuilding to be done. As they had done in the first innings, Critchley and Hughes added a few, but on 84 Critchley made room against the off spinner Drissell and was bowled. In the context of the game it was a cheap wicket to lose.
Hosein didn't last long, well-taken at slip and the decent-sized crowd, basking in sunshine and doubtless contemplating a long winter without their cricket 'fix' realised that this game was very much in the balance. Derbyshire were only 106 ahead and more were needed, beyond doubt.
After tea Hughes went on the attack, a square cut for four and then a sashay down the track and a six over long on. At the other end Anuj Dal was again busy and tidy, quick footwork and fast hands seeing him look as comfortable as anyone, as the nicks fell short or went wide of the slips but many more were met with a resolute straight bat until he was caught at slip after a stand of 29.
There were a couple of lusty blows from Hardus Viljoen, but the innings subsided to 157 all out. The 195 minute vigil of Alex Hughes was a magnificent effort, his unbeaten 55 when no one else made more than 17 was priceless for the cause.
179 to win became 150 by the close, but Gloucestershire lost their skipper to the first ball and Bracey clean bowled, both to Ferguson in that time.
The visitors will need to bat very well to win this, on a wicket that offers the bowlers plenty of help.
Conversely, Derbyshire will need to bowl badly and bowl the wrong people to lose it.
It should make for an absorbing couple of sessions of cricket and I look forward to seeing the dying embers of an excellent summer's entertainment.
Thereafter it was largely the Luis Reece show again, with the all-rounder completing figures of 7-20, the most economical for a seven wicket haul for the county since the legendary, nay infamous, Bill Bestwick at Burton on Trent in 1920. It is fair to say that the two are somewhat diametrically opposed as personalities and Luis is a considerably better batsman than Bill. Mind you, Bill took 1457 wickets for the county, so Luis has some way to go with a ball in his hand...
Today he bowled another spell of immaculate line and length, the batsmen seemingly unaware how to combat his left arm swing. When Lockie Ferguson held on to catch at mid wicket to take the seventh, he was instantly surrounded by his team mates, who had been commendably upbeat and chipper all morning. It was a superb spell of controlled swing bowling, yet in marked contrast to two dreadful overs bowled by Hardus Viljoen before he was withdrawn from the attack. In a low-scoring game, 34 extras conceded, sixteen byes and ten wides, is unacceptable at this level and I attribute little blame to the wicket-keeper. One ball that went to the fence would have challenged a wide leg slip to take and it is so frustrating to see. Ironically, Viljoen produced a beauty with his final ball to dismiss Higgins, there being little that the batsman could do before the catch was pouched expertly at slip by Wayne Madsen.
A lead of 21 could have been more with less profligate bowling by the fast bowlers and it seemed to me that our best chance of winning this in the final innings will be for the bulk of the bowling to be done by Messrs Palladino, Reece and Hughes. Runs will be at a premium and we can ill afford to give away freebies as we did first time around.
The batting procession continued as our second innings began, the skipper's final knock of the summer lasting just three balls before being given leg before. Madsen and Reece saw it through to lunch but both went soon afterwards, at 32-3 the home side in danger of giving away their fine work earlier.
The Gloucestershire bowlers did well again. I particularly liked the look of Ryan Higgins, who bristled aggression though not really having the pace for it. He nipped it around as he has all season, as did David Payne, a bowler I have admired for some time and the ball fizzed past the bat and rapped the pad with uneasy frequency.
Yet Alex Hughes and Tom Lace showed commendable fortitude and no little skill in adding a painstaking partnership. It was proper, attritional, fascinating county cricket. Alex always looks good in such situations and sells his wicket dearly, while my first 'proper' sighting of Lace was enjoyable. He showed sound technique against a moving ball and got his head down again after a nasty blow on the arm from one that lifted from a length. Probably not what he wanted to be on the end of, but for the watching Derbyshire bowlers, something that may have brought a smile to their faces.
Of course, on such a wicket danger lurks in every delivery and Lace fell leg before to Howell for a hard-earned seventeen. It was nothing impressive in the score book, but worth more in the context of the game. At 66-4, there was more rebuilding to be done. As they had done in the first innings, Critchley and Hughes added a few, but on 84 Critchley made room against the off spinner Drissell and was bowled. In the context of the game it was a cheap wicket to lose.
Hosein didn't last long, well-taken at slip and the decent-sized crowd, basking in sunshine and doubtless contemplating a long winter without their cricket 'fix' realised that this game was very much in the balance. Derbyshire were only 106 ahead and more were needed, beyond doubt.
After tea Hughes went on the attack, a square cut for four and then a sashay down the track and a six over long on. At the other end Anuj Dal was again busy and tidy, quick footwork and fast hands seeing him look as comfortable as anyone, as the nicks fell short or went wide of the slips but many more were met with a resolute straight bat until he was caught at slip after a stand of 29.
There were a couple of lusty blows from Hardus Viljoen, but the innings subsided to 157 all out. The 195 minute vigil of Alex Hughes was a magnificent effort, his unbeaten 55 when no one else made more than 17 was priceless for the cause.
179 to win became 150 by the close, but Gloucestershire lost their skipper to the first ball and Bracey clean bowled, both to Ferguson in that time.
The visitors will need to bat very well to win this, on a wicket that offers the bowlers plenty of help.
Conversely, Derbyshire will need to bowl badly and bowl the wrong people to lose it.
It should make for an absorbing couple of sessions of cricket and I look forward to seeing the dying embers of an excellent summer's entertainment.
Madsen's new deal completes good end of season work by Derbyshire
They are the best three players at the club, so it is simple. Whatever else Dave Houghton decides to do when he comes into his new role next week, he can rest assured that his two best batsmen and his most reliable bowler are with him for the foreseeable future.
Madsen's deal, taking him to the end of 2022, is effectively one that puts an end to any links with other counties. He will be 38/39 when this contract finishes; young enough perhaps to warrant one more at the county he has served so loyally and so well, but too old, one would think, to warrant the clamour of other counties.
As regular readers will know, I never gave real credibility to stories linking him with Yorkshire, likely the work of a canny agent trying to work the best deal for his client. He would still walk into any side in the country though and, for all that our dear neighbours have picked up Ben Slater, Ben Duckett and Joe Clarke, I don't think many Derbyshire supporters would swap Wayne for any of them.
The return of Dave Houghton, as he revealed in an interview with The Cricketer today, was a major factor in his signing the new deal. I know how highly he rates Houghton as a batting coach and we might even see the runs output increase next year as a result, even though he again eased past the thousand run mark for the season in this game.
In all likelihood, by the time he has finished this contract, only Kim Barnett will be ahead of Wayne in the Derbyshire batting records, if he maintains his current runs output. Additionally, with one eye on the future, his reputation as a legend of the club will be unsullied by a departure to a longstanding rival and his sports coaching business with his wife, Kyla can only benefit.
Then again, so could Derbyshire, because when he decides to call it a day, sometime in the future, one would have thought him a strong contender for a coaching role at the club. He will know that the move into such a role from playing doesn't always work well - look at Glen Chapple and Andrew Gale for examples - but he would be in a strong position, without doubt.
I'm thrilled. In watching John Morris, Chris Adams and Kim Barnett I saw what was the pinnacle of Derbyshire batting. Wayne has joined that group and, in all weathers and conditions, is up there just behind Barnett for me.
Enjoy the majesty of his batting for another four years, ladies and gentlemen.
Like all of our heroes, he will be a long time gone, so it is important to celebrate and enjoy his considerable talents while we can. Whatever the ECB do to our domestic game, that will now be for at least the next four years.
And, when you have done and said all, makes today a rather special one for all county supporters.
Happy Tuesday, everyone.
Monday, 24 September 2018
Derbyshire v Gloucestershire day 1
Derbyshire 184 (Reece 59)
Gloucestershire 100-5 (Reece 4-15)
Derbyshire lead by 84 runs
On day one of what is theoretically a four-day game, Luis Reece pretty much changed my plans for the next few days single-handed.
I will be at Derby for the next two days, which at today's rate will likely see the denouement, one way or the other, of this game on a wicket that seems to offer plenty of help for the bowlers. Like recent tracks at Derby, the movement seems to come once the roller's effect has gone off and both sides made decent starts before the collapse.
I just hope that Derbyshire don't come to regret the disappointing generosity that gifted Gloucestershire 25 runs in extras. On a day where there were a combined 22 byes, I would guess that there was some variable bounce which made life awkward for the wicket-keepers, but I would be disappointed with that number of free runs were I Derbyshire skipper.
Harvey Hosein's dropping of Chris Dent off Lockie Ferguson could have been costly, but the dismissal of the visiting skipper before the close was a key wicket, one of four for Luis Reece on a day that clearly showed what we have missed this summer.
As I have said before, seam bowling opening batsman are far from common and Reece took full advantage of the conditions by getting his swing going. With support at the other end from Tony Palladino, who took his fiftieth wicket of a fine summer, Derbyshire survived a collapse of their own after lunch to end the day slightly ahead.
Reece, together with a fifty stand between Alex Hughes and Matt Critchley , gave Derbyshire the upper hand and I would doubt the visitors would want to chase more than 200 in the final innings of the summer. A lead tomorrow would be handy and I hope to be down in time to see the end of the Gloucestershire innings, even allowing for that 10.30am start.
Here's hoping we can force home the slender advantage tomorrow, then end the summer on a high.
In closing, warm congratulations to Wayne Madsen, who passed the thousand run mark for the county for the fifth time in six summers.
What a modern day colossus he has been for us. I have no idea what we would be like without his considerable ability.
Let's hope it is some years before we find out.
Gloucestershire 100-5 (Reece 4-15)
Derbyshire lead by 84 runs
On day one of what is theoretically a four-day game, Luis Reece pretty much changed my plans for the next few days single-handed.
I will be at Derby for the next two days, which at today's rate will likely see the denouement, one way or the other, of this game on a wicket that seems to offer plenty of help for the bowlers. Like recent tracks at Derby, the movement seems to come once the roller's effect has gone off and both sides made decent starts before the collapse.
I just hope that Derbyshire don't come to regret the disappointing generosity that gifted Gloucestershire 25 runs in extras. On a day where there were a combined 22 byes, I would guess that there was some variable bounce which made life awkward for the wicket-keepers, but I would be disappointed with that number of free runs were I Derbyshire skipper.
Harvey Hosein's dropping of Chris Dent off Lockie Ferguson could have been costly, but the dismissal of the visiting skipper before the close was a key wicket, one of four for Luis Reece on a day that clearly showed what we have missed this summer.
As I have said before, seam bowling opening batsman are far from common and Reece took full advantage of the conditions by getting his swing going. With support at the other end from Tony Palladino, who took his fiftieth wicket of a fine summer, Derbyshire survived a collapse of their own after lunch to end the day slightly ahead.
Reece, together with a fifty stand between Alex Hughes and Matt Critchley , gave Derbyshire the upper hand and I would doubt the visitors would want to chase more than 200 in the final innings of the summer. A lead tomorrow would be handy and I hope to be down in time to see the end of the Gloucestershire innings, even allowing for that 10.30am start.
Here's hoping we can force home the slender advantage tomorrow, then end the summer on a high.
In closing, warm congratulations to Wayne Madsen, who passed the thousand run mark for the county for the fifth time in six summers.
What a modern day colossus he has been for us. I have no idea what we would be like without his considerable ability.
Let's hope it is some years before we find out.
Sunday, 23 September 2018
Derbyshire v Gloucestershire preview
This is it. The final game in a season where Derbyshire's cricket has at times touched excellence, but at others has fallen frustratingly short. It will not escape the player's notice that had strong winning positions been converted we could have been playing for third place here, which would have been a special effort. As it is they could finish anywhere between fourth and seventh and it should be mentioned that in a possible new format eight-team division two that would be a second place finish. Not bad at all...
The Derbyshire squad is as follows:
Billy Godleman
Tom Lace
Luis Reece
Wayne Madsen
Alex Hughes
Matt CritchleyHarvey Hosein
Anuj Dal
Tony Palladino
Hardus Viljoen
Lockie Ferguson
James Taylor
Hamidullah Qadri
Tom Lace returns after missing the Middlesex match as loans usually work, his employers not wanting him to embarrass them with a big score. Looking at their batting, it would be no real surprise to see this as a possible top seven for next summer, as a season in division two would undoubtedly be better for his development than one in second team cricket.
The final place would appear to be between Qadri, Dal and Taylor, depending on the look of the wicket.So no Rampaul, no Gary Wilson, no Daryn Smit and again, no Will Davis.
Our visitors could, with a win, swap places with us and travel with the following squad:
Dent (c), Hammond, Bracey, Howell, Roderick, Cockbain, J.Taylor, Higgins, Charlesworth, Miles, Payne, M.Taylor, Drissell.
Chris Dent has a fine record against us, while Miles Hammond has restored a famous name to the county ranks and had a very good first summer. Ryan Higgins has proved an inspired signing from Middlesex and they will fight for the positive result.
I look forward to seeing a good amount of the cricket from the second day onwards, around family commitments and, with a good weather forecast for the work, expect to see a positive result.
I will stick my neck out and predict a Derbyshire win, sending us all into the winter in good heart.
Postscript - Somerset today announced the release of Fin Trenouth, who at nineteen would appear very likely to pick up a deal elsewhere. A hard-hitting middle-order batsman who can keep wicket if required, he would be a good pick up for a discerning county.
Having played in our last game of the second team summer, he must be on our radar and may be worth a shout, at the right age to get better and a price we should be able to afford.
I would think there would be plenty of interest in the former England under-nineteen.
We'll see.
The Derbyshire squad is as follows:
Billy Godleman
Tom Lace
Luis Reece
Wayne Madsen
Alex Hughes
Matt CritchleyHarvey Hosein
Anuj Dal
Tony Palladino
Hardus Viljoen
Lockie Ferguson
James Taylor
Hamidullah Qadri
Tom Lace returns after missing the Middlesex match as loans usually work, his employers not wanting him to embarrass them with a big score. Looking at their batting, it would be no real surprise to see this as a possible top seven for next summer, as a season in division two would undoubtedly be better for his development than one in second team cricket.
The final place would appear to be between Qadri, Dal and Taylor, depending on the look of the wicket.So no Rampaul, no Gary Wilson, no Daryn Smit and again, no Will Davis.
Our visitors could, with a win, swap places with us and travel with the following squad:
Dent (c), Hammond, Bracey, Howell, Roderick, Cockbain, J.Taylor, Higgins, Charlesworth, Miles, Payne, M.Taylor, Drissell.
Chris Dent has a fine record against us, while Miles Hammond has restored a famous name to the county ranks and had a very good first summer. Ryan Higgins has proved an inspired signing from Middlesex and they will fight for the positive result.
I look forward to seeing a good amount of the cricket from the second day onwards, around family commitments and, with a good weather forecast for the work, expect to see a positive result.
I will stick my neck out and predict a Derbyshire win, sending us all into the winter in good heart.
Postscript - Somerset today announced the release of Fin Trenouth, who at nineteen would appear very likely to pick up a deal elsewhere. A hard-hitting middle-order batsman who can keep wicket if required, he would be a good pick up for a discerning county.
Having played in our last game of the second team summer, he must be on our radar and may be worth a shout, at the right age to get better and a price we should be able to afford.
I would think there would be plenty of interest in the former England under-nineteen.
We'll see.
Saturday, 22 September 2018
One game to go
Four more days of cricket to go for Derbyshire, weather permitting, then the players can go away on hard earned holidays, while Dave Houghton arrives at the club and gets his bearings.
Signing Billy Godleman and Tony Palladino to new deals is good work already. Hopefully a new contract for Wayne Madsen isn't far behind, his current deal finishing at the end of 2019. With Luis Reece, Matt Critchley and Alex Hughes all contracted to the end of 2020, the nucleus of the squad that most would envisage in a first choice line up is in place.
That's the good news. The bad is that of the others there are no certainties to be with us in two summers time, not to mention 2019.
There's the wicket-keeping situation first of all. Harvey Hosein may have done enough, especially with his match-winning innings at Northampton, to secure a new deal. Yet that would be dependent on Dave Houghton's understanding of his worth. I think his glove work was better at the end of the summer, the result of hard work, but only time will tell if he can maintain a high standard throughout a long summer.
Of course, he needs opportunity to do that and my guess would be that unless there is a hidden gem elsewhere in county second team cricket he will get that chance next year. Neither Daryn Smit or Gary Wilson have done enough with the bat to take precedence, though we all know the former's ability with the gloves. In the season's closing weeks he has appeared a peripheral figure, however and one of Houghton's early jobs is to look at his wicket keepers and see what can be done. If Smit could score the runs he managed in South Africa, his glove work would make him a shoo-in, but he hasn't done that.
Nor has Gary Wilson. He is a nice bloke, but the reality is that our vice-captain has scored two half centuries, highest score 66, in all cricket this year. Given that he has spent a fair part of it in the top five, it isn't enough by some distance.
Then there's the seam bowling. We are bowling sides out now, something we singularly failed to do in the pre-Barnett era, but there are question marks against both Hardus Viljoen and Ravi Rampaul. Both are among our highest earners, but Viljoen's 36 wickets at 32 isn't, for me, a strong argument on being value for money. There have been some hostile spells, but more dreadful ones than we should expect at this level. Pace without direction is no use and when Hardus goes off kilter it is generally spectacular.
As for Rampaul, thirteen wickets at 50 is a dismal return and the recurrence of his breathing issues at Lord's is worrying for his first-class future. At times he can bowl some canny deliveries, but too often he has looked worryingly ordinary and not especially fit.
As for the younger players, I'd be confident that Hamidullah Qadri has a long term future, one that I hope can be secured, but for others things are less clear cut. Will Davis played one first-class match all summer, which tells its own story. I would be surprised to see him retained, even more so if someone else didn't give him a try.
There's a good bowler in there, but maybe the mental side of the first-class game isn't yet right. Were it so he was surely worth more senior cricket than he got. Perhaps a change of environment will see him prosper. Maybe if his too fragile body bulks up he could do it, but it doesn't look good for a lad who has a lot of talent.
I think Brodrick and Gleadall will get opportunities, in time, but I don't think Anuj Dal has done enough to be retained. He seems a really nice lad, is terrific in the field and like a whippet between the wickets, but he hasn't scored enough runs, either in the second or first team. He always looks classy and stylish, as I have written before, but that counts for nothing if there are no runs in the scorebook.
We do need competition in the middle order and I would like to see at least one batsman and one bowler come in over the winter, aside from the change in overseas players that each season seems to bring.
As it stands the opening eleven for 2019 is a long way from completion.
Signing Billy Godleman and Tony Palladino to new deals is good work already. Hopefully a new contract for Wayne Madsen isn't far behind, his current deal finishing at the end of 2019. With Luis Reece, Matt Critchley and Alex Hughes all contracted to the end of 2020, the nucleus of the squad that most would envisage in a first choice line up is in place.
That's the good news. The bad is that of the others there are no certainties to be with us in two summers time, not to mention 2019.
There's the wicket-keeping situation first of all. Harvey Hosein may have done enough, especially with his match-winning innings at Northampton, to secure a new deal. Yet that would be dependent on Dave Houghton's understanding of his worth. I think his glove work was better at the end of the summer, the result of hard work, but only time will tell if he can maintain a high standard throughout a long summer.
Of course, he needs opportunity to do that and my guess would be that unless there is a hidden gem elsewhere in county second team cricket he will get that chance next year. Neither Daryn Smit or Gary Wilson have done enough with the bat to take precedence, though we all know the former's ability with the gloves. In the season's closing weeks he has appeared a peripheral figure, however and one of Houghton's early jobs is to look at his wicket keepers and see what can be done. If Smit could score the runs he managed in South Africa, his glove work would make him a shoo-in, but he hasn't done that.
Nor has Gary Wilson. He is a nice bloke, but the reality is that our vice-captain has scored two half centuries, highest score 66, in all cricket this year. Given that he has spent a fair part of it in the top five, it isn't enough by some distance.
Then there's the seam bowling. We are bowling sides out now, something we singularly failed to do in the pre-Barnett era, but there are question marks against both Hardus Viljoen and Ravi Rampaul. Both are among our highest earners, but Viljoen's 36 wickets at 32 isn't, for me, a strong argument on being value for money. There have been some hostile spells, but more dreadful ones than we should expect at this level. Pace without direction is no use and when Hardus goes off kilter it is generally spectacular.
As for Rampaul, thirteen wickets at 50 is a dismal return and the recurrence of his breathing issues at Lord's is worrying for his first-class future. At times he can bowl some canny deliveries, but too often he has looked worryingly ordinary and not especially fit.
As for the younger players, I'd be confident that Hamidullah Qadri has a long term future, one that I hope can be secured, but for others things are less clear cut. Will Davis played one first-class match all summer, which tells its own story. I would be surprised to see him retained, even more so if someone else didn't give him a try.
There's a good bowler in there, but maybe the mental side of the first-class game isn't yet right. Were it so he was surely worth more senior cricket than he got. Perhaps a change of environment will see him prosper. Maybe if his too fragile body bulks up he could do it, but it doesn't look good for a lad who has a lot of talent.
I think Brodrick and Gleadall will get opportunities, in time, but I don't think Anuj Dal has done enough to be retained. He seems a really nice lad, is terrific in the field and like a whippet between the wickets, but he hasn't scored enough runs, either in the second or first team. He always looks classy and stylish, as I have written before, but that counts for nothing if there are no runs in the scorebook.
We do need competition in the middle order and I would like to see at least one batsman and one bowler come in over the winter, aside from the change in overseas players that each season seems to bring.
As it stands the opening eleven for 2019 is a long way from completion.
Friday, 21 September 2018
Middlesex v Derbyshire day 4 - and Palladino signs new deal
Middlesex 423 and 199-7 dec
Derbyshire 295 and 210 (Godleman 105 not)
Middlesex won by 117 runs
A typical Billy Godleman century, brim full of cuts, nudges, glances and nurdles, was not enough to enable Derbyshire to salvage a draw at Lord's today.
He enjoyed some luck, as any batsman needed on the last two days. There was both variable bounce and lateral movement, the ball beating the bat with nigh monotonous frequency all day, but Billy did as Billy does and produced an outstanding century that made up exactly half of the Derbyshire total. He reached it with a straight six and his delight in scoring a century against the club that released him was tangible.
By then the Derbyshire innings was in disarray and no one else suggested permanence, which leaves us in sixth place in the table with just next week's game against Gloucestershire to go.
I will be down for the last three days of that match, or some of them, between doing stuff for my parents. Hopefully there will be an opportunity to meet up with friends old and new before the winter hits us once more.
The big news of the day, as well as the best, was that Tony Palladino has signed a new two-year deal with the county, that takes him to the end of 2020.
Why wouldn't he? For all the international bowlers who have come in during the summer, Tony has outbowled them all. He's much slower than all of them, but week on week shows the merits of bowling tight lines and lengths. The club's statement made it clear that his role will be a playing one only, and clarified that a bowling coach will be appointed to work under Dave Houghton.
While I think he would be slogged in T20, there is a role for Tony in fifty-over cricket and everyone knows that whenever he plays you will get one hundred per cent from him. With a team of Palladinos you could take on a lot of sides and I am thrilled to see his stay extended.
At the other end of the spectrum, it is farewell to Steve Stubbings today, who leaves to return to Australia. The club has announced its intention to recruit a bowling coach in his place, which makes sense when Dave Houghton can take care of the batting side.
I wish Steve, a genial giant of a man who always has a smile on his face, the very best in the country where he grew up.
He will do well.
Derbyshire 295 and 210 (Godleman 105 not)
Middlesex won by 117 runs
A typical Billy Godleman century, brim full of cuts, nudges, glances and nurdles, was not enough to enable Derbyshire to salvage a draw at Lord's today.
He enjoyed some luck, as any batsman needed on the last two days. There was both variable bounce and lateral movement, the ball beating the bat with nigh monotonous frequency all day, but Billy did as Billy does and produced an outstanding century that made up exactly half of the Derbyshire total. He reached it with a straight six and his delight in scoring a century against the club that released him was tangible.
By then the Derbyshire innings was in disarray and no one else suggested permanence, which leaves us in sixth place in the table with just next week's game against Gloucestershire to go.
I will be down for the last three days of that match, or some of them, between doing stuff for my parents. Hopefully there will be an opportunity to meet up with friends old and new before the winter hits us once more.
The big news of the day, as well as the best, was that Tony Palladino has signed a new two-year deal with the county, that takes him to the end of 2020.
Why wouldn't he? For all the international bowlers who have come in during the summer, Tony has outbowled them all. He's much slower than all of them, but week on week shows the merits of bowling tight lines and lengths. The club's statement made it clear that his role will be a playing one only, and clarified that a bowling coach will be appointed to work under Dave Houghton.
While I think he would be slogged in T20, there is a role for Tony in fifty-over cricket and everyone knows that whenever he plays you will get one hundred per cent from him. With a team of Palladinos you could take on a lot of sides and I am thrilled to see his stay extended.
At the other end of the spectrum, it is farewell to Steve Stubbings today, who leaves to return to Australia. The club has announced its intention to recruit a bowling coach in his place, which makes sense when Dave Houghton can take care of the batting side.
I wish Steve, a genial giant of a man who always has a smile on his face, the very best in the country where he grew up.
He will do well.
Thursday, 20 September 2018
Middlesex v Derbyshire day 3
Middlesex 423 and 199-7 (Robson 73, Critchley 4-60)
Derbyshire 295 (Critchley 105)
Middlesex lead by 327 runs
A century by Matt Critchley and some clean hitting by Hardus Viljoen and Lockie Ferguson saw Derbyshire safely past the follow on mark today at Lord's, but anyone watching the afternoon and evening play will be in no doubt that they will face a massive task to save this game tomorrow.
With balls lifting and keeping low in equal measure, batting was far from easy, especially in the morning session, which was delayed by overnight rain. Tony Palladino was leg before to one that kept very low, a ball after fending off one that lifted sharply. Ferguson's highest score of the summer included two clean hits for six, while Viljoen played with good sense. I think Hardus could be an even better batsman, because when he plays straight he has immense power and looks a good batsman. It is generally when the ugly cross-bat heaves come in that he gets into bother, but he served us well today.
Critchley reached his century with panache, which is his way, but got out to an unnecessary hook shot when there was still work to do. His innings was a fine one, however and he can be proud of being the youngest Derbyshire player to score a century at Lord's (Stan Worthington the previous youngest, courtesy of David Griffin on Twitter).
Middlesex built quickly on their lead but lost quick wickets before and after tea. Malan was very unlucky to be caught by Alex Hughes from a full blooded sweep, the ball going to him from Gary Wilson's heel at short leg, but the leg spinner bowled pretty well to complete (almost) a fine all round match.
Lockie Ferguson bowled some very quick deliveries and rapped our former loan player Martin Andersson on the helmet. For what it is worth, I think he bowls too much short stuff and for me his four day bowling is a bouncer/yorker combo to which good players become wise. He must be a handful to face, for sure, but I don't think he has the variations of Duanne Olivier. Mind you, I'd have him as a T20 player next season in a heartbeat...
Much to do tomorrow, then, before the season reaches its conclusion at Derby next week.
Postscript - two centuries in the match for Derbyshire seconds by Scotland's Andy Umeed against Sussex, as the side were robbed of a win by bad light. He followed a first innings unbeaten 128 with 101, as the run chase ended fifteen short of victory with four wickets in hand.
The batsman has been on Warwickshire's staff and recorded what is believed to be the second slowest championship century when he made one in 429 minutes against Lancashire last summer. One can only assume he is soon to be released by them and he could scarce have made a better impression than that.
Also in the second team is Somerset's batsman (and sometimes wicket-keeper) Finlay Trenouth. He once made 330 for their under-17s and has played for England under-19s with success. He has a reputation as a punishing batsman, but hasn't perhaps kicked on this summer at a county with a lot of young talent.
No hares around the park that we are signing them, but at least we are looking at options for another year. Or, if you are cynical, getting a team together from various sources for the final game of the summer.
Time will tell, my friends.
I will be back tomorrow.
Derbyshire 295 (Critchley 105)
Middlesex lead by 327 runs
A century by Matt Critchley and some clean hitting by Hardus Viljoen and Lockie Ferguson saw Derbyshire safely past the follow on mark today at Lord's, but anyone watching the afternoon and evening play will be in no doubt that they will face a massive task to save this game tomorrow.
With balls lifting and keeping low in equal measure, batting was far from easy, especially in the morning session, which was delayed by overnight rain. Tony Palladino was leg before to one that kept very low, a ball after fending off one that lifted sharply. Ferguson's highest score of the summer included two clean hits for six, while Viljoen played with good sense. I think Hardus could be an even better batsman, because when he plays straight he has immense power and looks a good batsman. It is generally when the ugly cross-bat heaves come in that he gets into bother, but he served us well today.
Critchley reached his century with panache, which is his way, but got out to an unnecessary hook shot when there was still work to do. His innings was a fine one, however and he can be proud of being the youngest Derbyshire player to score a century at Lord's (Stan Worthington the previous youngest, courtesy of David Griffin on Twitter).
Middlesex built quickly on their lead but lost quick wickets before and after tea. Malan was very unlucky to be caught by Alex Hughes from a full blooded sweep, the ball going to him from Gary Wilson's heel at short leg, but the leg spinner bowled pretty well to complete (almost) a fine all round match.
Lockie Ferguson bowled some very quick deliveries and rapped our former loan player Martin Andersson on the helmet. For what it is worth, I think he bowls too much short stuff and for me his four day bowling is a bouncer/yorker combo to which good players become wise. He must be a handful to face, for sure, but I don't think he has the variations of Duanne Olivier. Mind you, I'd have him as a T20 player next season in a heartbeat...
Much to do tomorrow, then, before the season reaches its conclusion at Derby next week.
Postscript - two centuries in the match for Derbyshire seconds by Scotland's Andy Umeed against Sussex, as the side were robbed of a win by bad light. He followed a first innings unbeaten 128 with 101, as the run chase ended fifteen short of victory with four wickets in hand.
The batsman has been on Warwickshire's staff and recorded what is believed to be the second slowest championship century when he made one in 429 minutes against Lancashire last summer. One can only assume he is soon to be released by them and he could scarce have made a better impression than that.
Also in the second team is Somerset's batsman (and sometimes wicket-keeper) Finlay Trenouth. He once made 330 for their under-17s and has played for England under-19s with success. He has a reputation as a punishing batsman, but hasn't perhaps kicked on this summer at a county with a lot of young talent.
No hares around the park that we are signing them, but at least we are looking at options for another year. Or, if you are cynical, getting a team together from various sources for the final game of the summer.
Time will tell, my friends.
I will be back tomorrow.
Middlesex v Derbyshire day 2
Middlesex 423 (Holden 119 not)
Derbyshire 222-6 (Critchley 87 not, Dal 19 not)
Derbyshire trail by 201 runs
A season highest score of 87 not out from Matt Critchley gave Derbyshire a chance of avoiding the follow on at Lord's yesterday, after a top order collapse suggested we might be doing so well before the end of day 2.
It has been a disappointing summer for Critchley who, aside from a stellar performance at Chesterfield hasn't really delivered this year. No one doubts the talent that lies within, but he will hope to kick on next year under Dave Houghton, as a player of such talent should be scoring more runs than he has managed in 2018.
The same could be said about a few others, of course, and it is quite damning that with a potential three innings to go for everyone, the closest run tally to Wayne Madsen's 977 is over three hundred runs back in his slipstream. Wayne passed eleven thousand first-class runs yesterday and remains the Derbyshire wicket most prized by the opposition.
I am sure that Luis Reece would have matched Madsen this year and it was nice to see him back in the middle yesterday. A big innings would have been nice, but also a fairy tale after such a lay off, even though his leg before decision was deemed unlucky. At 62-4, when Harvey Hosein went second ball, we were looking down a barrel of considerable size.
Critchley and Billy Godleman began the fightback before the skipper's departure for a battling 28 in 150 minutes of batting. Gary Wilson also dug in and helped to add a further sixty runs, before an ugly swipe across the line saw him dismissed for 31. Like Critchley, a key component of the Derbyshire 'engine room' has to be disappointed with a summer in which his highest first-class score is just 66.
Anuj Dal kept the entertaining Critchley company until the close of play, surviving an appealed slip catch en route when the ball was deemed to have bounced. We will need more runs from both of them today to avoid the follow on, though Middlesex may choose not enforce it.
Plenty still to play for in this match, then, but the home side are well on top after two days.
Derbyshire 222-6 (Critchley 87 not, Dal 19 not)
Derbyshire trail by 201 runs
A season highest score of 87 not out from Matt Critchley gave Derbyshire a chance of avoiding the follow on at Lord's yesterday, after a top order collapse suggested we might be doing so well before the end of day 2.
It has been a disappointing summer for Critchley who, aside from a stellar performance at Chesterfield hasn't really delivered this year. No one doubts the talent that lies within, but he will hope to kick on next year under Dave Houghton, as a player of such talent should be scoring more runs than he has managed in 2018.
The same could be said about a few others, of course, and it is quite damning that with a potential three innings to go for everyone, the closest run tally to Wayne Madsen's 977 is over three hundred runs back in his slipstream. Wayne passed eleven thousand first-class runs yesterday and remains the Derbyshire wicket most prized by the opposition.
I am sure that Luis Reece would have matched Madsen this year and it was nice to see him back in the middle yesterday. A big innings would have been nice, but also a fairy tale after such a lay off, even though his leg before decision was deemed unlucky. At 62-4, when Harvey Hosein went second ball, we were looking down a barrel of considerable size.
Critchley and Billy Godleman began the fightback before the skipper's departure for a battling 28 in 150 minutes of batting. Gary Wilson also dug in and helped to add a further sixty runs, before an ugly swipe across the line saw him dismissed for 31. Like Critchley, a key component of the Derbyshire 'engine room' has to be disappointed with a summer in which his highest first-class score is just 66.
Anuj Dal kept the entertaining Critchley company until the close of play, surviving an appealed slip catch en route when the ball was deemed to have bounced. We will need more runs from both of them today to avoid the follow on, though Middlesex may choose not enforce it.
Plenty still to play for in this match, then, but the home side are well on top after two days.
Tuesday, 18 September 2018
Middlesex v Derbyshire day 1
Middlesex 350-8 (Robson 134, Holden 96 not, Palladino 4-66, Viljoen 2-74)
v Derbyshire
At 298-3, fifteen overs from the close, Middlesex were very much in the ascendancy and Derbyshire were looking down a barrel.
Yet by the close, the score had reached 350-8 and we were still very much in it, thanks to a superb spell of 4-3 in fifteen balls by who else? Tony Palladino. 49 wickets for the season now and another superb effort that kept us in the match.
Hardus Viljoen bowled quickly, but there was a little punishment for both he and Lockie Ferguson today. Palladino was his usual self, but Robson made a fine century, while Holden looks set to join him tomorrow, having benefited from a drop by Gary Wilson at slip earlier in his innings.
Hopefully we can wrap things up quickly tomorrow morning and then show similar application when it is our turn to bat.
More from me tomorrow.
v Derbyshire
At 298-3, fifteen overs from the close, Middlesex were very much in the ascendancy and Derbyshire were looking down a barrel.
Yet by the close, the score had reached 350-8 and we were still very much in it, thanks to a superb spell of 4-3 in fifteen balls by who else? Tony Palladino. 49 wickets for the season now and another superb effort that kept us in the match.
Hardus Viljoen bowled quickly, but there was a little punishment for both he and Lockie Ferguson today. Palladino was his usual self, but Robson made a fine century, while Holden looks set to join him tomorrow, having benefited from a drop by Gary Wilson at slip earlier in his innings.
Hopefully we can wrap things up quickly tomorrow morning and then show similar application when it is our turn to bat.
More from me tomorrow.
Monday, 17 September 2018
There's a welcome return for Luis Reece to the Derbyshire ranks tomorrow, as Derbyshire play Middlesex at Lord's in their penultimate game of the summer.
A fourteen man squad has been announced and I guess the final eleven will depend on whether Reece is cleared to bowl or not. Based on recent performances Anuj Dal and Daryn Smit will be two to miss out, with, again on form, Gary Wilson the other. The squad in full:
1. Billy Godleman
27. Tom Lace
10. Luis Reece
77. Wayne Madsen
18. Alex Hughes
14. Gary Wilson
20. Matt Critchley16. Harvey Hosein
65. Anuj Dal
11. Daryn Smit
28. Tony Palladino
7. Hardus Viljoen
69. Lockie Ferguson
41. Ravi Rampaul
Middlesex has named a 15-man squad that is a mix of youth and experience. They welcome Tim Murtagh and James Harris back from injury, while Martin Andersson, recently on loan with us, may well play against us tomorrow.
Their squad: Malan, Andersson, Bamber, Eskinazi, Fuller, Gubbins, Harris, Holden, Morgan, Murtagh, Rayner, Robson, Scott, Stirling, White.
Can we do three in a row?
Why not? There's a talented squad in the Derbyshire ranks and they will be full of confidence.
Should be a good game, before next week's season finale at Derby.
A fourteen man squad has been announced and I guess the final eleven will depend on whether Reece is cleared to bowl or not. Based on recent performances Anuj Dal and Daryn Smit will be two to miss out, with, again on form, Gary Wilson the other. The squad in full:
1. Billy Godleman
27. Tom Lace
10. Luis Reece
77. Wayne Madsen
18. Alex Hughes
14. Gary Wilson
20. Matt Critchley16. Harvey Hosein
65. Anuj Dal
11. Daryn Smit
28. Tony Palladino
7. Hardus Viljoen
69. Lockie Ferguson
41. Ravi Rampaul
Middlesex has named a 15-man squad that is a mix of youth and experience. They welcome Tim Murtagh and James Harris back from injury, while Martin Andersson, recently on loan with us, may well play against us tomorrow.
Their squad: Malan, Andersson, Bamber, Eskinazi, Fuller, Gubbins, Harris, Holden, Morgan, Murtagh, Rayner, Robson, Scott, Stirling, White.
Can we do three in a row?
Why not? There's a talented squad in the Derbyshire ranks and they will be full of confidence.
Should be a good game, before next week's season finale at Derby.
Friday, 14 September 2018
Future a little clearer after Northampton win
Aside from the euphoria of the win at Northampton yesterday, a few things became clearer for me and perhaps a few other people.
Harvey Hosein must surely be a part of it.
There was a phlegmatic calm, not to mention a soundness of technique that was impressive in Hosein's innings yesterday. There was plenty of playing and missing by batsmen all day, but my recollection was that little went past his bat as he played straight and largely went well forward. This minimised the danger of lbw to the one that nipped back and, with the full bat width to work with in playing through the 'V', he batted with the minimum of fuss and maximum common sense.
Since his return to the side he has scored 58, 38, 8, 66 not, 10, 31, 30, 54 not. There is no arguing with such scores and he fully deserves a regular spot while he contributes in such a manner.
There is still the question mark over his role as wicket keeper, but what I have seen of him of late has been more impressive. Critics might point to 23 byes in the game just finished, as well as a grounded catch, but in Hardus Viljoen we have a bowler of notoriously scatter gun manner who often leaves the keeper with no chance when he fires one down leg side from wide of the crease.
It is a shame that we already have three wicket-keepers, because yesterday on Twitter Ned Eckersley announced that he was leaving Leicestershire. At 29 he would be the right age for us and, with a batting average north of thirty and fourteen centuries, the right calibre. As he has done at times for Leicestershire, he is good enough to play as a batsman alone, as is Hosein, of course. He always seems to do well against us and I would reckon that he will be known to Billy Godleman from their time on the Middlesex staff.
I wouldn't discount that one, but it would be dependent on money being available, which we don't know. It would also mean we had four wicket-keepers on the staff, but I could see merit in either Gary Wilson or Daryn Smit getting the second team captaincy next year. I don't think James Kettleborough has made the requisite runs to continue in the role and there would be merit in either of them taking it on, together with a coaching remit, under David Houghton.
Finally, for now, Anuj Dal. I am not yet convinced that a contract should be forthcoming and think that the next two games, should he play, are crucial for him.
He looks good at the crease, composed, wristy and classy. Yet the weight of runs to reinforce that at this level are not there. You could argue that at number eight he won't get the opportunity, but he has played a lot of classy cameos at different levels this year without the big scores to back up his claims.
In some ways it mirrors Dominic Telo, who some of you will remember. He came from South Africa on a Kolpak deal, looked balanced and classy at the crease, yet made no big scores to back up his obvious talent. Telo looked so composed that you were always convinced that today was the big one, yet it never happened.
Like Telo, Dal can obviously play, but I suspect that unless he converts an opportunity in the closing weeks of the season he will struggle for a permanent deal.
We'll see.
Harvey Hosein must surely be a part of it.
There was a phlegmatic calm, not to mention a soundness of technique that was impressive in Hosein's innings yesterday. There was plenty of playing and missing by batsmen all day, but my recollection was that little went past his bat as he played straight and largely went well forward. This minimised the danger of lbw to the one that nipped back and, with the full bat width to work with in playing through the 'V', he batted with the minimum of fuss and maximum common sense.
Since his return to the side he has scored 58, 38, 8, 66 not, 10, 31, 30, 54 not. There is no arguing with such scores and he fully deserves a regular spot while he contributes in such a manner.
There is still the question mark over his role as wicket keeper, but what I have seen of him of late has been more impressive. Critics might point to 23 byes in the game just finished, as well as a grounded catch, but in Hardus Viljoen we have a bowler of notoriously scatter gun manner who often leaves the keeper with no chance when he fires one down leg side from wide of the crease.
It is a shame that we already have three wicket-keepers, because yesterday on Twitter Ned Eckersley announced that he was leaving Leicestershire. At 29 he would be the right age for us and, with a batting average north of thirty and fourteen centuries, the right calibre. As he has done at times for Leicestershire, he is good enough to play as a batsman alone, as is Hosein, of course. He always seems to do well against us and I would reckon that he will be known to Billy Godleman from their time on the Middlesex staff.
I wouldn't discount that one, but it would be dependent on money being available, which we don't know. It would also mean we had four wicket-keepers on the staff, but I could see merit in either Gary Wilson or Daryn Smit getting the second team captaincy next year. I don't think James Kettleborough has made the requisite runs to continue in the role and there would be merit in either of them taking it on, together with a coaching remit, under David Houghton.
Finally, for now, Anuj Dal. I am not yet convinced that a contract should be forthcoming and think that the next two games, should he play, are crucial for him.
He looks good at the crease, composed, wristy and classy. Yet the weight of runs to reinforce that at this level are not there. You could argue that at number eight he won't get the opportunity, but he has played a lot of classy cameos at different levels this year without the big scores to back up his claims.
In some ways it mirrors Dominic Telo, who some of you will remember. He came from South Africa on a Kolpak deal, looked balanced and classy at the crease, yet made no big scores to back up his obvious talent. Telo looked so composed that you were always convinced that today was the big one, yet it never happened.
Like Telo, Dal can obviously play, but I suspect that unless he converts an opportunity in the closing weeks of the season he will struggle for a permanent deal.
We'll see.
Thursday, 13 September 2018
Northamptonshire v Derbyshire day 4
Derbyshire 222 and 234-9 (Madsen 62, Hosein 54 not out)
Derbyshire won by 1 wicket
Phew!
You can have all the T20s that your heart desires, but this was proper, nerve-jangling, nail-biting, stomach-churning stuff. Four days of cricket that was like a prize fight, the sides trading blows and in turn gaining the ascendancy, before it all came down to one ball left in an over, Nathan Buck to bowl it to Ravi Rampaul.
To be fair to Ravi, batting exploits haven't littered his career like confetti at a wedding, but here he faced up to a bowler who had bowled well and with great hostility. It may have been the last delivery of the over, but it could have been the last of the match.
Yet after threatening a starring role, Buck blew his lines. A shortish ball, on Rampaul's hip, which he flicked with Caribbean wristiness to fine leg for four. Perhaps the worst ball that Buck bowled at the wrong time, but there will be no complaints in the Derbyshire camp.
In a summer that has been littered with close matches, this was up there with the best of them. Tony Palladino finished off the home innings this morning in quick time, before the early loss of Billy Godleman confirmed that the run chase would be a challenging one.
Yet the subsequent 94 run second-wicket partnership between the impressive Tom Lace and the always impressive Wayne Madsen suggested that we might stroll it, against the odds. They took their partnership into the afternoon before Lace went, then Madsen's dismissal put the game back in the balance. His excellent 62 left him 48 runs short of another thousand in the season, a fine effort.
The collapse was on when Gary Wilson inexplicably called for a single that was never there, then Matt Critchley, short of runs and confidence, was caught at slip. 116-2 had become 122-5 in the blink of an eye and the home side were suddenly favourites, with 111 still to win.
Then came Harvey Hosein. For the rest of the afternoon the youngster never looked in trouble, for the simple reason that he, like Madsen and Lace before him, played straight and through the 'V'. Batsmen got in trouble here when they played across the line and although Anuj Dal and Hardus Viljoen lent important support, we still needed nine when last man Rampaul sauntered to the crease.
Yet Hosein showed his growing maturity by shielding him, as well as his growing confidence with an audacious ramp over fine leg to reach an outstanding fifty. He declined singles to protect Rampaul from the rampaging Buck and deserved to score the winning runs.
That honour went to Rampaul, whose fist pump as the ball crossed the boundary showed how much it meant to him. The teams cheers could be heard over the radio too, rightly so as their fourth win of a progressive summer took them to fourth in the table.
I have seen plenty of abject run chases by Derbyshire over the years. Less a chase, than the hesitant limping of an arthritic snail. Here they battled it out, fought their corner and, when the denouement came, it was our own light heavyweight who took us across the line.
More thoughts from me tomorrow, but Harvey Hosein can be a very proud young man tonight.
He has got back into the team and, rather echoing my comments of early season, he has grabbed it with both hands.
The role deserves to be his now.
The spoils go to Derbyshire, after a fantastic game of cricket.
Talking Point: time for a transfer system?
The world of county cricket has been hyper-active for the past few weeks, with players changing counties with almost undue haste. In most cases the move has been from a so-called 'smaller' county to one of the bigger, Test ground clubs, who have the greatest income to enable them to make an offer that cannot be refused, or to simply buy out a contract.
While the move of Alex Lees from Yorkshire to Durham bucked the trend, he was a peripheral figure in the white rose camp and his move can be firmly labelled under 'greater opportunities'. Yet Durham have also signed Ben Raine, a cricketer I admire, from Leicestershire, who have spiralled after a decent mid-season spell. They also look likely to lose Zak Chappell to Nottinghamshire, which is hardly untrodden turf from a movement angle.
Aneurin Donald has gone from Glamorgan to Hampshire, Liam Norwell and Craig Miles will leave Gloucestershire for Warwickshire, while Ben Duckett and Ben Slater have moved to Nottinghamshire. The list is not exclusive but is indicative of a trend - the rich are getting richer AND they are taking the cream of the talent from elsewhere. The poor are not just getting poorer, they will soon be in a state of penury.
I have no issue with people moving to further their careers. We all do it and it is a right for everyone to improve their lot in life. Yet the counties who in many cases spend years in the development of a youngster from a very early age lose both the player and his ability to win games, yet get no compensation whatsoever. That money might enable them to retain another talent, or at least recruit someone from elsewhere who may go some way to being an adequate replacement.
Football is far from perfect, but if player A from a smaller club is the target of another, they get compensated to their valuation of the player, quite often with add-ons if that player moves elsewhere or gains international recognition.
Cricket clubs get nothing.
If the sport is to continue to be a competition between eighteen first-class counties, rather than one between eight elite and ten feeder ones, there needs to be recognition of the work and money that has gone into player development.
Take the case of Ben Slater. He was at the end of his contract, so was within his rights to look at the best offer available to him. Derbyshire, with a playing budget substantially lower, offered the best they felt they could do. Nottinghamshire simply trumped that figure, as you can when you have more in the first place.
If they had to pay Derbyshire a fee of, say £25K on top that, it might level the playing field a little. In the case of players in contract, if they had to pay £25K per year outstanding on that contract, as well as that transfer fee, you might see greater loyalty and less of the movement that resembles the national train network at times. At the very least, it would be money to put back into player development or to make a difference to their own signing budget.
There may be a greater chance of players gaining national selection from division one, but there would be a delicious irony if either Lancashire or Yorkshire, as seems likely, get relegated to division two this year.
Such status is unlikely to see Jos Buttler ignored, while one assumes that the raft of Engand players in the Yorkshire camp, including Joe Root, will not be blanked because of their only occasional appearances in the game's second tier. Either way it means a Test ground county will play at a lower level, which may provoke a few wry smiles around the circuit.
My even greater concern is that the game goes the same way as Scottish football, where Celtic have such a monopoly that you can largely predict the winners of trophies before the season starts. It is going that way with Surrey, who are strolling division one to be county champions and have already reinforced a squad awash with talent by signing Liam Plunkett from Yorkshire and Jordan Clark from Lancashire.
Maybe it is to reinforce their appeal 'oop north', but they look set to dominate the county game over the next few years. With a playing budget that is to ours what Moby Dick is to Nemo the rainbow fish, the playing field is not just unlevel, it has more of a 'north face of the Eiger' perspective.
As always, I appreciate your thoughts, but would be surprised if there was great dissension on this one...
While the move of Alex Lees from Yorkshire to Durham bucked the trend, he was a peripheral figure in the white rose camp and his move can be firmly labelled under 'greater opportunities'. Yet Durham have also signed Ben Raine, a cricketer I admire, from Leicestershire, who have spiralled after a decent mid-season spell. They also look likely to lose Zak Chappell to Nottinghamshire, which is hardly untrodden turf from a movement angle.
Aneurin Donald has gone from Glamorgan to Hampshire, Liam Norwell and Craig Miles will leave Gloucestershire for Warwickshire, while Ben Duckett and Ben Slater have moved to Nottinghamshire. The list is not exclusive but is indicative of a trend - the rich are getting richer AND they are taking the cream of the talent from elsewhere. The poor are not just getting poorer, they will soon be in a state of penury.
I have no issue with people moving to further their careers. We all do it and it is a right for everyone to improve their lot in life. Yet the counties who in many cases spend years in the development of a youngster from a very early age lose both the player and his ability to win games, yet get no compensation whatsoever. That money might enable them to retain another talent, or at least recruit someone from elsewhere who may go some way to being an adequate replacement.
Football is far from perfect, but if player A from a smaller club is the target of another, they get compensated to their valuation of the player, quite often with add-ons if that player moves elsewhere or gains international recognition.
Cricket clubs get nothing.
If the sport is to continue to be a competition between eighteen first-class counties, rather than one between eight elite and ten feeder ones, there needs to be recognition of the work and money that has gone into player development.
Take the case of Ben Slater. He was at the end of his contract, so was within his rights to look at the best offer available to him. Derbyshire, with a playing budget substantially lower, offered the best they felt they could do. Nottinghamshire simply trumped that figure, as you can when you have more in the first place.
If they had to pay Derbyshire a fee of, say £25K on top that, it might level the playing field a little. In the case of players in contract, if they had to pay £25K per year outstanding on that contract, as well as that transfer fee, you might see greater loyalty and less of the movement that resembles the national train network at times. At the very least, it would be money to put back into player development or to make a difference to their own signing budget.
There may be a greater chance of players gaining national selection from division one, but there would be a delicious irony if either Lancashire or Yorkshire, as seems likely, get relegated to division two this year.
Such status is unlikely to see Jos Buttler ignored, while one assumes that the raft of Engand players in the Yorkshire camp, including Joe Root, will not be blanked because of their only occasional appearances in the game's second tier. Either way it means a Test ground county will play at a lower level, which may provoke a few wry smiles around the circuit.
My even greater concern is that the game goes the same way as Scottish football, where Celtic have such a monopoly that you can largely predict the winners of trophies before the season starts. It is going that way with Surrey, who are strolling division one to be county champions and have already reinforced a squad awash with talent by signing Liam Plunkett from Yorkshire and Jordan Clark from Lancashire.
Maybe it is to reinforce their appeal 'oop north', but they look set to dominate the county game over the next few years. With a playing budget that is to ours what Moby Dick is to Nemo the rainbow fish, the playing field is not just unlevel, it has more of a 'north face of the Eiger' perspective.
As always, I appreciate your thoughts, but would be surprised if there was great dissension on this one...
Northamptonshire v Derbyshire day 3
Northamptonshire 255 and 198-8 (Viljoen 4-51, Rampaul 3-53)
Derbyshire 222 (Hughes 75, Lace 38)
Northamptonshire lead by 231 runs
There's a battle royal going on going on at Northampton, on a wicket where runs can be scored with due care, technique and diligence, but bowlers can get their reward with bowling in the right areas.
So it proved in the final session for Derbyshire, though my gut feeling is that we let the home side get away in the first innings and in the afternoon session yesterday.
There were four wickets for Hardus Viljoen yesterday, though still a few of those horrific balls that makes the wicket-keeper despair. There were also three wickets for Ravi Rampaul, including an excellent caught and bowled that saw him get down faster than one might expect for a man of his build.
It does look like we will need to make something close to the game's highest score to win this one, though and that could be a challenge on a fourth day wicket.
Not impossible though, and with all results possible the game should be well worth following today.
Derbyshire 222 (Hughes 75, Lace 38)
Northamptonshire lead by 231 runs
There's a battle royal going on going on at Northampton, on a wicket where runs can be scored with due care, technique and diligence, but bowlers can get their reward with bowling in the right areas.
So it proved in the final session for Derbyshire, though my gut feeling is that we let the home side get away in the first innings and in the afternoon session yesterday.
There were four wickets for Hardus Viljoen yesterday, though still a few of those horrific balls that makes the wicket-keeper despair. There were also three wickets for Ravi Rampaul, including an excellent caught and bowled that saw him get down faster than one might expect for a man of his build.
It does look like we will need to make something close to the game's highest score to win this one, though and that could be a challenge on a fourth day wicket.
Not impossible though, and with all results possible the game should be well worth following today.
Tuesday, 11 September 2018
Northamptonshire v Derbyshire day 2
Northamptonshire 255
Derbyshire 118-4 (Hughes 74 not)
A rain-shortened day at Wantage Road, where Alex Hughes continued a fine knock and Tom Lace, together with Gary Wilson, departed before the rains came.
The state of the game, with two decent days of forecast to come, suggests a positive result may well be possible here.
Tomorrow's Derbyshire batting may largely dictate in which direction it goes.
Here's hoping Alex progresses serenely to a century and he gets the support from the plenty of batting to come.
Derbyshire 118-4 (Hughes 74 not)
A rain-shortened day at Wantage Road, where Alex Hughes continued a fine knock and Tom Lace, together with Gary Wilson, departed before the rains came.
The state of the game, with two decent days of forecast to come, suggests a positive result may well be possible here.
Tomorrow's Derbyshire batting may largely dictate in which direction it goes.
Here's hoping Alex progresses serenely to a century and he gets the support from the plenty of batting to come.
Monday, 10 September 2018
Northamptonshire v Derbyshire day 1
Northamptonshire 255 (Hughes 4-57, Palladino 3-25)
Derbyshire 60-2 (Hughes 38 not)
Honours fairly even at Northampton today, with Derbyshire letting the home side off the hook from 170-8 to their final tally. The early loss of Billy Godleman and Wayne Madsen could have precipitated a collapse, but Alex Hughes followed earlier fine bowling with a lively knock.
There was another immaculate bowling spell from Tony Palladino and an opportunity to build on this tomorrow.
No time for more from me today, after a long day, but I will be back in greater detail tomorrow.
Derbyshire 60-2 (Hughes 38 not)
Honours fairly even at Northampton today, with Derbyshire letting the home side off the hook from 170-8 to their final tally. The early loss of Billy Godleman and Wayne Madsen could have precipitated a collapse, but Alex Hughes followed earlier fine bowling with a lively knock.
There was another immaculate bowling spell from Tony Palladino and an opportunity to build on this tomorrow.
No time for more from me today, after a long day, but I will be back in greater detail tomorrow.
Sunday, 9 September 2018
Northamptonshire v Derbyshire preview
Logic suggests, having seen the trauma caused by Derbyshire's pace attack in the Vitality Blast game at Wantage Road this summer, that the wicket for tomorrow's four day game between the sides may not be so quick.
If it were, then both Lockie Ferguson and Hardus Viljoen would sleep tonight as if it was the night before Christmas.
Viljoen for Ravi Rampaul would be the only change I would expect to a winning Derbyshire side, unless the pace is not there, in which case they may go for the greater control of the latter.
As for our hosts, they will be without Ben Duckett, who has moved to Nottinghamshire, Richard Gleeson, who has moved to Lancashire and Rory Kleinveldt, who has left the county after sterling service.
Alex Wakely captains a side with some inexperience, but one that includes Ben Cotton in the announced thirteen.
Their squad: Wakely, Buck, Cobb, Cotton, Curran, Hutton, Levi, Procter, Rossington, Sanderson, Thurston, Zaib, Vasconcelos
I'm in bullish mood and so will go for a Derbyshire win here, building on the excellent win over Glamorgan and taking us into the season's final two games with a smile on our faces.
What do you think?
If it were, then both Lockie Ferguson and Hardus Viljoen would sleep tonight as if it was the night before Christmas.
Viljoen for Ravi Rampaul would be the only change I would expect to a winning Derbyshire side, unless the pace is not there, in which case they may go for the greater control of the latter.
As for our hosts, they will be without Ben Duckett, who has moved to Nottinghamshire, Richard Gleeson, who has moved to Lancashire and Rory Kleinveldt, who has left the county after sterling service.
Alex Wakely captains a side with some inexperience, but one that includes Ben Cotton in the announced thirteen.
Their squad: Wakely, Buck, Cobb, Cotton, Curran, Hutton, Levi, Procter, Rossington, Sanderson, Thurston, Zaib, Vasconcelos
I'm in bullish mood and so will go for a Derbyshire win here, building on the excellent win over Glamorgan and taking us into the season's final two games with a smile on our faces.
What do you think?
Postbag catch up
I will get my apologies in early, but this past week or so I have had way too many emails for me to personally answer all of them. Thank you to everyone and please do keep mailing me your thoughts, but working, together with family commitments, has limited my time!
My thoughts on a few recurring themes. Rikki Wessels as a possible signing from Nottinghamshire, where his contract is up? Don't see it, personally. For one thing we couldn't get close on the contract side, unless part of the winter plans is a major bank heist....Top player, but don't see it happening.
We need to be realistic on the signing front. My understanding is that there is some money there for signings, but far more realistic is ensuring that key personnel are on deals sufficient to stop the predators circling.
I have a feeling that the announcement of David Houghton will soothe a few furled brows and a good few players will be pleased at the thought of working with him. He will go into the job aware of the financial side and also know that unless something radical is done with under performing senior players that little can be done this winter.
Yes, they could, theoretically, look to come to an agreement with some players, but that will cost money and we would then be left with little to replace them. Houghton already said, on local radio in the week, that we might look at the loan market and Minor Counties to strengthen the squad but that could be hit or miss. Yet no more than any other signing, for that matter. Should it work, there would be a high level of satisfaction.
The top three scorers in the Minor Counties this year make interesting reading. Sam Arthurton, at Norfolk, who played a game for our seconds earlier in the summer has nearly 1200 runs at 62. Previously on the staff at Middlesex, he has a fine record, as does Alex Kervezee, previously at Worcestershire. A boundary short of a thousand, he looked a player of talent before losing his contract there and moving to Shropshire, where he has scored a lot of runs and is still only 28. There's also a 21-year old batsman named Louis Kimber in the top three, who plays at Lincolnshire and has come through their age groups.
Maybe opportunity will knock for one of them? On the bowling front the leading wicket-takers appear to be over-thirty, with the exception of Lincolnshire's Alex Willerton, who has had trials with Worcestershire.
There will be diamonds there, just as there will in the loan market. Both Tom Lace and Martin Andersson seem to have plenty ahead of them at Middlesex, while Surrey's pace bowling riches, soon to be enhanced by Liam Plunkett and Jordan Clark, are embarrassingly good. There's two Currans, Morkel, Dernbach, Meaker and Clarke, even before considering the claims of Conor McKerr, who we had on loan last summer.
How many do they need?
And question two, can we get one of them for next season. Please?
My thoughts on a few recurring themes. Rikki Wessels as a possible signing from Nottinghamshire, where his contract is up? Don't see it, personally. For one thing we couldn't get close on the contract side, unless part of the winter plans is a major bank heist....Top player, but don't see it happening.
We need to be realistic on the signing front. My understanding is that there is some money there for signings, but far more realistic is ensuring that key personnel are on deals sufficient to stop the predators circling.
I have a feeling that the announcement of David Houghton will soothe a few furled brows and a good few players will be pleased at the thought of working with him. He will go into the job aware of the financial side and also know that unless something radical is done with under performing senior players that little can be done this winter.
Yes, they could, theoretically, look to come to an agreement with some players, but that will cost money and we would then be left with little to replace them. Houghton already said, on local radio in the week, that we might look at the loan market and Minor Counties to strengthen the squad but that could be hit or miss. Yet no more than any other signing, for that matter. Should it work, there would be a high level of satisfaction.
The top three scorers in the Minor Counties this year make interesting reading. Sam Arthurton, at Norfolk, who played a game for our seconds earlier in the summer has nearly 1200 runs at 62. Previously on the staff at Middlesex, he has a fine record, as does Alex Kervezee, previously at Worcestershire. A boundary short of a thousand, he looked a player of talent before losing his contract there and moving to Shropshire, where he has scored a lot of runs and is still only 28. There's also a 21-year old batsman named Louis Kimber in the top three, who plays at Lincolnshire and has come through their age groups.
Maybe opportunity will knock for one of them? On the bowling front the leading wicket-takers appear to be over-thirty, with the exception of Lincolnshire's Alex Willerton, who has had trials with Worcestershire.
There will be diamonds there, just as there will in the loan market. Both Tom Lace and Martin Andersson seem to have plenty ahead of them at Middlesex, while Surrey's pace bowling riches, soon to be enhanced by Liam Plunkett and Jordan Clark, are embarrassingly good. There's two Currans, Morkel, Dernbach, Meaker and Clarke, even before considering the claims of Conor McKerr, who we had on loan last summer.
How many do they need?
And question two, can we get one of them for next season. Please?
Friday, 7 September 2018
Morning after thoughts
It is always nice to be able to write a piece the morning after and reflect on a win.
While one has to take into account the standard of opposition, and Glamorgan, with a couple of exceptions, were a poor side, you can only beat what is in front of you. Our win was the result of a real team effort on a tricky wicket, with most of the side contributing well. Runs were harder to come by and I think you see the real merits of a batsman on such tracks.
Many a flat track bully has boosted their season average on flat wickets and against poor attacks and there are plenty in the international game whose impressive average is inflated by some big innings against lesser sides.
Conversely, there's a certain pressure with bowling on wickets that help you. It's nice when you rip your fingers across the seam and it jags sideways, but there is then an expectation that you do your stuff. As Edwin Smith once said to me, most of our wickets in the 50's were prepared for Gladwin and Jackson, who seldom let us down, but he had to be ready to do his stuff when the opposition prepared a turner.
There's been a lot of discussion about the signings of Tom Lace and Martin Andersson. I have previously made the point that Lace was a 'horses for courses' signing as an opener and he has impressed so far. My understanding, from a comment made at the member's meeting, is that he 'might' be available for next season, though whether as a loan signing or on a permanent deal wasn't made clear. He is contracted to Middlesex until the end of 2020, so a loan would seem the most likely scenario, if there is one.
Despite a comment elsewhere on the blog, Andersson is contracted to the same date and only recently signed a new deal. Both, one would think, might better develop their careers playing in our first team than Middlesex seconds and they have plenty of players ahead of them at that county.
I would have no issue with either, from what we have so far seen and they appear to have fitted in well. The question, as I have said before, is the inference it makes about our own development structure.
I know we have no opening batsman and no seam bowlers so far advanced in their development. My concern is the message it sends out about the current younger players and about the academy structure itself.
At present, we seem to develop a handful, let them go when they haven't made it by 21 and then start again. Leicestershire picked up Parkinson and Taylor and are rumoured to be in the wings should Will Davis be released. Tom Knight was messed around dreadfully and there are plenty who argued the case for Ben Cotton's retention.
Either these players were poorly managed or they were never quite good enough. Yet we need to look at this. Why play Tom Wood all season, watch him score a thousand runs and not play him, given opportunity? What does it say to Callum Brodrick?
The second team played last week at Chesterfield and there was no coach with them. Mal Loye was apparently away with the Academy and it cannot be right that the players we are hoping will step into the senior side have no one to guide, nurture or fight their cause. How can you know, from a distance, that a fifty was classy and skilled, or full of edges and mistimed shots? Or that five wickets were well-earned, rather than the result of poor shots and blinding catches?
I cannot now see a way into the side this season for Anuj Dal. It may be that the consensus is of style but no substance, but perhaps we will never know. For what its worth, whatever structure David Houghton comes up with must surely include someone who handles the second team and someone else to take the academy. Otherwise you end up with someone spread too thinly to do either job well. Like a good few others, I have struggled to get a handle on many of the second team players this year and too often it has appeared a bit of a rag, tag and bobtail outfit.
It's a shame and needs to be sorted over the winter.
Postscript: I note that the giant 21-year old Zimababwe fast bowler Blessing Muzarabani, who has held talks with Northamptonshire, has not yet signed for the county.
Muzarabani, who quit international cricket for a county career, played for our seconds earlier in the season.
I just wonder if he might be on Dave Houghton's radar? Were there any interest, or the money for that matter, the Head of Cricket's status as a national cricket legend would do us no harm.
Post postscript.. He signed this morning for Northants. Maybe I reminded him he had a contract offer to sign...
While one has to take into account the standard of opposition, and Glamorgan, with a couple of exceptions, were a poor side, you can only beat what is in front of you. Our win was the result of a real team effort on a tricky wicket, with most of the side contributing well. Runs were harder to come by and I think you see the real merits of a batsman on such tracks.
Many a flat track bully has boosted their season average on flat wickets and against poor attacks and there are plenty in the international game whose impressive average is inflated by some big innings against lesser sides.
Conversely, there's a certain pressure with bowling on wickets that help you. It's nice when you rip your fingers across the seam and it jags sideways, but there is then an expectation that you do your stuff. As Edwin Smith once said to me, most of our wickets in the 50's were prepared for Gladwin and Jackson, who seldom let us down, but he had to be ready to do his stuff when the opposition prepared a turner.
There's been a lot of discussion about the signings of Tom Lace and Martin Andersson. I have previously made the point that Lace was a 'horses for courses' signing as an opener and he has impressed so far. My understanding, from a comment made at the member's meeting, is that he 'might' be available for next season, though whether as a loan signing or on a permanent deal wasn't made clear. He is contracted to Middlesex until the end of 2020, so a loan would seem the most likely scenario, if there is one.
Despite a comment elsewhere on the blog, Andersson is contracted to the same date and only recently signed a new deal. Both, one would think, might better develop their careers playing in our first team than Middlesex seconds and they have plenty of players ahead of them at that county.
I would have no issue with either, from what we have so far seen and they appear to have fitted in well. The question, as I have said before, is the inference it makes about our own development structure.
I know we have no opening batsman and no seam bowlers so far advanced in their development. My concern is the message it sends out about the current younger players and about the academy structure itself.
At present, we seem to develop a handful, let them go when they haven't made it by 21 and then start again. Leicestershire picked up Parkinson and Taylor and are rumoured to be in the wings should Will Davis be released. Tom Knight was messed around dreadfully and there are plenty who argued the case for Ben Cotton's retention.
Either these players were poorly managed or they were never quite good enough. Yet we need to look at this. Why play Tom Wood all season, watch him score a thousand runs and not play him, given opportunity? What does it say to Callum Brodrick?
The second team played last week at Chesterfield and there was no coach with them. Mal Loye was apparently away with the Academy and it cannot be right that the players we are hoping will step into the senior side have no one to guide, nurture or fight their cause. How can you know, from a distance, that a fifty was classy and skilled, or full of edges and mistimed shots? Or that five wickets were well-earned, rather than the result of poor shots and blinding catches?
I cannot now see a way into the side this season for Anuj Dal. It may be that the consensus is of style but no substance, but perhaps we will never know. For what its worth, whatever structure David Houghton comes up with must surely include someone who handles the second team and someone else to take the academy. Otherwise you end up with someone spread too thinly to do either job well. Like a good few others, I have struggled to get a handle on many of the second team players this year and too often it has appeared a bit of a rag, tag and bobtail outfit.
It's a shame and needs to be sorted over the winter.
Postscript: I note that the giant 21-year old Zimababwe fast bowler Blessing Muzarabani, who has held talks with Northamptonshire, has not yet signed for the county.
Muzarabani, who quit international cricket for a county career, played for our seconds earlier in the season.
I just wonder if he might be on Dave Houghton's radar? Were there any interest, or the money for that matter, the Head of Cricket's status as a national cricket legend would do us no harm.
Post postscript.. He signed this morning for Northants. Maybe I reminded him he had a contract offer to sign...
Thursday, 6 September 2018
Derbyshire v Glamorgan day 3
Derbyshire 251 and 171
Glamorgan 121 and 132 (Palladino 4-52, Andersson 4-25, Ferguson 2-25)
Derbyshire won by 169 runs
In an ending that could not have been bettered to a day that could have been script-written, Tony Palladino took the last wicket of the match, to end up with ten in a game for the first time.
It was a superb exhibition of class seam bowling. I watched all of today's play and, like all the best exponents of the art, was impressed by his control over the ball, seemingly having it on a piece of string as he jagged it this way and that, according to his will.
That is forty wickets in four-day cricket this summer and it is inconceivable that he won't be offered another deal for 2019. With question marks over much of the rest of the attack, his presence next summer gives us someone to rely on, a player who lends control and penetration in equal measure.
He's a class act and it was apposite that the final wicket came courtesy of a catch from Lockie Ferguson, also impressive today. His pace never dropped and some of his bouncers were searingly quick. The yorkers were equally brisk and the delivery that removed Chris Cooke's off stump was classic fast bowling, forcing the batsman back with several short balls then ripping out the timber with a fast and full pitched delivery.
Completing a pleasing triumvirate, Martin Andersson took the other four wickets for just 25 runs on his birthday, which completed a pretty handy debut. I liked what I saw of him and after some thought came to the conclusion that there was a touch of Jonathan Clare about his action. The run up is nothing special, but there is plenty of strength in the shoulders and he has a quicker ball and decent bouncer.
All in all there was little to dislike in this display. Special mention too for Harvey Hosein, who I thought kept pretty well today, on a wicket where some balls flew and others barely bounced at all. He led a good fielding display in which the catches were held, not always the case in recent seasons.
As I said last night, if we could replicate such pitches all summer long, we could turn the the 3aaa County Ground into fortress Derby.
We've not done that since the halcyon playing days of Sir Kim Barnett.
That home hoodoo is well and truly gone now.
Glamorgan 121 and 132 (Palladino 4-52, Andersson 4-25, Ferguson 2-25)
Derbyshire won by 169 runs
In an ending that could not have been bettered to a day that could have been script-written, Tony Palladino took the last wicket of the match, to end up with ten in a game for the first time.
It was a superb exhibition of class seam bowling. I watched all of today's play and, like all the best exponents of the art, was impressed by his control over the ball, seemingly having it on a piece of string as he jagged it this way and that, according to his will.
That is forty wickets in four-day cricket this summer and it is inconceivable that he won't be offered another deal for 2019. With question marks over much of the rest of the attack, his presence next summer gives us someone to rely on, a player who lends control and penetration in equal measure.
He's a class act and it was apposite that the final wicket came courtesy of a catch from Lockie Ferguson, also impressive today. His pace never dropped and some of his bouncers were searingly quick. The yorkers were equally brisk and the delivery that removed Chris Cooke's off stump was classic fast bowling, forcing the batsman back with several short balls then ripping out the timber with a fast and full pitched delivery.
Completing a pleasing triumvirate, Martin Andersson took the other four wickets for just 25 runs on his birthday, which completed a pretty handy debut. I liked what I saw of him and after some thought came to the conclusion that there was a touch of Jonathan Clare about his action. The run up is nothing special, but there is plenty of strength in the shoulders and he has a quicker ball and decent bouncer.
All in all there was little to dislike in this display. Special mention too for Harvey Hosein, who I thought kept pretty well today, on a wicket where some balls flew and others barely bounced at all. He led a good fielding display in which the catches were held, not always the case in recent seasons.
As I said last night, if we could replicate such pitches all summer long, we could turn the the 3aaa County Ground into fortress Derby.
We've not done that since the halcyon playing days of Sir Kim Barnett.
That home hoodoo is well and truly gone now.
Wednesday, 5 September 2018
Derbyshire v Glamorgan day 2
Derbyshire 251 and 171 (Hughes 57)
Glamorgan 121 (Palladino 6-29) and 16-1
Glamorgan need 286 runs to win
Before this game, somewhat facetiously and in the light of a dodgy weather forecast for the fourth day, I suggested that Derbyshire would need to beat Glamorgan in three.
Tomorrow, barring something special by the visiting batsmen that would require to be matched in its ineptitude by our bowlers, we should do just that, with plenty of runs and time to spare.
Maybe, at last, in the season's dying embers, we have stumbled across a formula that might work for us moving forward. If we can't prepare fast wickets, let's have some slower ones with variable bounce and movement that plays right into the hands of that most admirable of professionals, Tony Palladino.
There will be those who say he is 35 years old and only plays four-day cricket, perhaps decrying him as a one-dimensional cricketer. I can only say, with Tony out of contract at the end of the summer, that I wish we had a few similar players on the staff, because his level of consistency is remarkable. He took his 300th first-class wicket for us today and has served the county nobly.
If the wicket is in his favour, he takes wickets. If it isn't, he keeps things quiet. 37 wickets at 19 each underlines his importance to this side and I would like to see him given at least another year. There would be worse ideas than his remaining on the coaching staff too, because a bowler such as he can teach plenty to younger bowlers. He keeps himself fit and could feasibly play on for another couple of summers yet.
Today, before and after lunch, he filleted the Glamorgan innings and reduced it from a position of dominance to a wreck in no time. Lockie Ferguson produced trademark yorkers and in the twinkling of an eye we had an unlikely, but very handy lead of 130 runs. It rather put yesterday's efforts, especially that of Billy Godleman, into perspective, yet the second innings began with his early dismissal, cricket being the greatest of levellers.
Today's hero was Alex Hughes, who overcame a narrow escape when he lost his grip on his bat, which slipped over his shoulder and narrowly missed the stumps. He made a watchful 57 in two and a half hours of diligence, while Harvey Hosein added 31 to take the lead past 300.
Psychologically it made a sizeable hill into a mountain and we should win tomorrow by a hundred and plenty. The visitors are left to make the game's highest score by some distance, on a wicket where a batsman can never consider himself 'in'. The loss of their overseas player, Stephen Cook, to that man Palladino before the close made things even tougher and they should face a struggle tomorrow.
Always assuming that we don't bowl like we did at Durham, of course, but this attack has personnel of greater discipline and I expect Tony and Ravi Rampaul to be key men tomorrow, with Ferguson on hand with his howitzers for the tail.
Fingers crossed we all have our smiley faces on, tomorrow evening.
Glamorgan 121 (Palladino 6-29) and 16-1
Glamorgan need 286 runs to win
Before this game, somewhat facetiously and in the light of a dodgy weather forecast for the fourth day, I suggested that Derbyshire would need to beat Glamorgan in three.
Tomorrow, barring something special by the visiting batsmen that would require to be matched in its ineptitude by our bowlers, we should do just that, with plenty of runs and time to spare.
Maybe, at last, in the season's dying embers, we have stumbled across a formula that might work for us moving forward. If we can't prepare fast wickets, let's have some slower ones with variable bounce and movement that plays right into the hands of that most admirable of professionals, Tony Palladino.
There will be those who say he is 35 years old and only plays four-day cricket, perhaps decrying him as a one-dimensional cricketer. I can only say, with Tony out of contract at the end of the summer, that I wish we had a few similar players on the staff, because his level of consistency is remarkable. He took his 300th first-class wicket for us today and has served the county nobly.
If the wicket is in his favour, he takes wickets. If it isn't, he keeps things quiet. 37 wickets at 19 each underlines his importance to this side and I would like to see him given at least another year. There would be worse ideas than his remaining on the coaching staff too, because a bowler such as he can teach plenty to younger bowlers. He keeps himself fit and could feasibly play on for another couple of summers yet.
Today, before and after lunch, he filleted the Glamorgan innings and reduced it from a position of dominance to a wreck in no time. Lockie Ferguson produced trademark yorkers and in the twinkling of an eye we had an unlikely, but very handy lead of 130 runs. It rather put yesterday's efforts, especially that of Billy Godleman, into perspective, yet the second innings began with his early dismissal, cricket being the greatest of levellers.
Today's hero was Alex Hughes, who overcame a narrow escape when he lost his grip on his bat, which slipped over his shoulder and narrowly missed the stumps. He made a watchful 57 in two and a half hours of diligence, while Harvey Hosein added 31 to take the lead past 300.
Psychologically it made a sizeable hill into a mountain and we should win tomorrow by a hundred and plenty. The visitors are left to make the game's highest score by some distance, on a wicket where a batsman can never consider himself 'in'. The loss of their overseas player, Stephen Cook, to that man Palladino before the close made things even tougher and they should face a struggle tomorrow.
Always assuming that we don't bowl like we did at Durham, of course, but this attack has personnel of greater discipline and I expect Tony and Ravi Rampaul to be key men tomorrow, with Ferguson on hand with his howitzers for the tail.
Fingers crossed we all have our smiley faces on, tomorrow evening.
Tuesday, 4 September 2018
Derbyshire v Glamorgan day 1
Derbyshire 251 (Godleman 95)
Glamorgan 20-0
Aside from a sterling effort from captain Billy Godleman, once again leading from the front with a dogged 95, there wasn't much to admire in Derbyshire's batting today.
I didn't see any of it because of work, and it was always going to be an easy decision for Glamorgan to bowl, but 251, while more than we looked like getting, is just about enough to keep us in the match - IF we bowl well.
There was a debut for Martin Andersson, but neither he nor Tom Lace made many on a wicket that offered help to all of the bowlers. It made the skipper's vigil all the more impressive, while those around him tried alternately to hit their way to success and grind it out with equal lack of success. 26 was the next highest score, which tells its own story.
The more I think about it, the more I agree with a number who have filled my postbag in recent days. The only way the signing of Lace and Andersson makes any sense, at this stage of the summer, is if we have a possibility of engaging them for next year.
Why not play Anuj Dal? Or Calum Brodrick? Or Tom Wood, who has played pretty much every match for the second team this summer? All three are players of talent and are crucially ours. Might we not learn a little more of their worth if they played a few first team games, even if it was to confirm that they weren't quite 'there'?
I don't think it fair on them or on the Academy set up if we are bypassing it and taking two players from that of another county.
If the players within our own Academy are not doing well enough, it poses questions about the current set up and the role of Mal Loye. If they are, surely, when there is little at stake bar pride, we should be playing them?
I'm a bit baffled by it all, to be honest.
Hopefully the coming weeks might reveal a few of the reasons.
Glamorgan 20-0
Aside from a sterling effort from captain Billy Godleman, once again leading from the front with a dogged 95, there wasn't much to admire in Derbyshire's batting today.
I didn't see any of it because of work, and it was always going to be an easy decision for Glamorgan to bowl, but 251, while more than we looked like getting, is just about enough to keep us in the match - IF we bowl well.
There was a debut for Martin Andersson, but neither he nor Tom Lace made many on a wicket that offered help to all of the bowlers. It made the skipper's vigil all the more impressive, while those around him tried alternately to hit their way to success and grind it out with equal lack of success. 26 was the next highest score, which tells its own story.
The more I think about it, the more I agree with a number who have filled my postbag in recent days. The only way the signing of Lace and Andersson makes any sense, at this stage of the summer, is if we have a possibility of engaging them for next year.
Why not play Anuj Dal? Or Calum Brodrick? Or Tom Wood, who has played pretty much every match for the second team this summer? All three are players of talent and are crucially ours. Might we not learn a little more of their worth if they played a few first team games, even if it was to confirm that they weren't quite 'there'?
I don't think it fair on them or on the Academy set up if we are bypassing it and taking two players from that of another county.
If the players within our own Academy are not doing well enough, it poses questions about the current set up and the role of Mal Loye. If they are, surely, when there is little at stake bar pride, we should be playing them?
I'm a bit baffled by it all, to be honest.
Hopefully the coming weeks might reveal a few of the reasons.
Monday, 3 September 2018
Derbyshire v Glamorgan preview
The penultimate home game of the cricket season and Derbyshire welcome Glamorgan to the 3aaa County Ground tomorrow. It is the latest example of barmy scheduling, playing a match Tuesday to Friday when few can easily attend. Anyone would think the ECB were attempting to marginalise the county game...
Middlesex all-rounder Martin Andersson has signed a short-term loan deal to the end of the summer, one which had a few knives out on Twitter earlier. I know little about the lad, except that he is 21, is a good batsman and bowls right arm medium. I can only assume that there may be some longer term potential, as otherwise his skill set is very similar to Anuj Dal, who I and a good few others would like to see getting an opportunity before the end of the summer.
It will also be interesting to see the final line up tomorrow, with Gary Wilson back from Ireland duty. It would be unfair were he to take the gloves over Harvey Hosein, but we appear to have a squad where a couple of deserving players will miss out.
I doubt our quicks will be especially enamoured with the wickets at Derby this summer and I don't expect it to be rock hard tomorrow, either. Slow and lifeless appears the order of the day this summer, and it has been frustrating when we have fielded an array of quicks. I know I have mentioned this before, but it points at a frustrating lack of cohesion in the planning. Why sign fast bowlers if we are preparing pudding tracks? Another thing for David Houghton to look at when he takes up his post.
The Derbyshire squad:
Billy Godleman
Tom Lace
Wayne Madsen
Alex Hughes
Gary Wilson
Matt CritchleyHarvey Hosein
Anuj Dal
Martin Andersson
Tony Palladino
Hardus Viljoen
Lockie Ferguson
Hamidullah Qadri
Ravi Rampaul
Were I picking tomorrow's side I would omit Wilson, Rampaul and Qadri, enabling others to make a case for themselves, though the latter could get a game if the wicket is dry
Glamorgan are bottom of the table and have only one win all summer in the four-day game. They have signed South African Stephen Cook for the rest of the season, while Graham Wagg returns to a ground where he was a firm favourite.
Their squad:
Cook, Brown, Cullen, Lloyd, Carlson, Cooke, Wagg, Hogan, Bull, Smith, Lawlor, Van der Gugten.
I'm going for a Derbyshire win here, although the last scheduled day looks set to be plagued by showers.
We'll just need to aim for a win in three days, then...
Middlesex all-rounder Martin Andersson has signed a short-term loan deal to the end of the summer, one which had a few knives out on Twitter earlier. I know little about the lad, except that he is 21, is a good batsman and bowls right arm medium. I can only assume that there may be some longer term potential, as otherwise his skill set is very similar to Anuj Dal, who I and a good few others would like to see getting an opportunity before the end of the summer.
It will also be interesting to see the final line up tomorrow, with Gary Wilson back from Ireland duty. It would be unfair were he to take the gloves over Harvey Hosein, but we appear to have a squad where a couple of deserving players will miss out.
I doubt our quicks will be especially enamoured with the wickets at Derby this summer and I don't expect it to be rock hard tomorrow, either. Slow and lifeless appears the order of the day this summer, and it has been frustrating when we have fielded an array of quicks. I know I have mentioned this before, but it points at a frustrating lack of cohesion in the planning. Why sign fast bowlers if we are preparing pudding tracks? Another thing for David Houghton to look at when he takes up his post.
The Derbyshire squad:
Billy Godleman
Tom Lace
Wayne Madsen
Alex Hughes
Gary Wilson
Matt CritchleyHarvey Hosein
Anuj Dal
Martin Andersson
Tony Palladino
Hardus Viljoen
Lockie Ferguson
Hamidullah Qadri
Ravi Rampaul
Were I picking tomorrow's side I would omit Wilson, Rampaul and Qadri, enabling others to make a case for themselves, though the latter could get a game if the wicket is dry
Glamorgan are bottom of the table and have only one win all summer in the four-day game. They have signed South African Stephen Cook for the rest of the season, while Graham Wagg returns to a ground where he was a firm favourite.
Their squad:
Cook, Brown, Cullen, Lloyd, Carlson, Cooke, Wagg, Hogan, Bull, Smith, Lawlor, Van der Gugten.
I'm going for a Derbyshire win here, although the last scheduled day looks set to be plagued by showers.
We'll just need to aim for a win in three days, then...
Sunday, 2 September 2018
Averages don't lie - the task awaiting Dave Houghton
There were decent individual efforts throughout the game, but that word is key, because all too seldom we have played as a tight team unit this summer. Each game has seen standout performances, but a positive result is dependent on there being enough of them. Too often we have fallen short.
Let's look at the batting, first of all. With an average of 46 and more runs (875) than anyone in the division, Wayne Madsen still sits atop it like a colossus. Yet of the others who average 40, the benchmark of a good county cricketer, Luis Reece has played little through injury, Tom Lace is only on loan (at least for now) and Ben Slater has gone to Nottinghamshire.
The skipper, despite an outstanding RLODC and good T20, but because of his selfless earlier demotion to the middle order where he isn't suited, averages 23. Alex Hughes averages 24 and Matt Critchley a shade over 30, but with a season-best of only 86.
Good players all, but none can be happy with such returns over a summer. If three of your top six average 25 between them, you will struggle to get match-winning runs on the board. Unless one of the others is Bradman...
Then there are the wicket-keepers. We have three, but none has yet done enough to confirm the role as their own. As senior players, neither Gary Wilson nor Daryn Smit has come close with the bat. I am prepared to cut a little slack for Harvey Hosein, who continues to show potential as a batsman, but for me is some way short of the required standard with the gloves.
The bowling? It is led by the evergreen Tony Palladino, whose thirty wickets at 22 and batting average of 26 is an example of the expectation from a solid county professional. Yet he is out of contract at season end. Hardus Viljoen has 28 wickets at 33, not close, for me, to requirements for a highly paid Kolpak, while Ravi Rampaul has a disastrous eight wickets at 62.
I accept these bowlers have done better in one-day formats, but the averages don't lie. The bottom line is that Dave Houghton comes into a club where we only have three players - Madsen, Godleman and Palladino - consistently delivering an acceptable level of performance. He will take us forward if he can get more from the others, or replace them with players who can do better.
Things are in a mess, at present. Only one player in the second team, Anuj Dal, warrants a run as a batsman, but he was omitted from the team in favour of a lad we brought in from Middlesex, Tom Lace. He did well, but may or may not be with us for longer than a few games. We also brought in Sean Ervine on loan for the remainder of the summer, who played two matches and announced his retirement with immediate effect. Whether that was because Dave Houghton told him he didn't see him in his plans I don't know, but to be fair to Ervine, at least he quit before his reputation as a gutsy county cricketer is tarnished by playing for too long.
It will be a big winter for Dave Houghton, who I welcome back to the county as a good and extremely able man. His reputation as a coach precedes him, but it is not yet clear as to whether he will do some of that coaching. I suspect his appointment will see us retain the services of Wayne Madsen, who I know rates the new coach highly, but he will surely need a bowling coach at the very least.
My preference was for someone new to the county and to some extent we have that, as only a handful will know Houghton from his earlier spells at the club. I was pleasantly surprised at the announcement of John Wright as an advisor/consultant, as I didn't think he would want to stay on, but he has since said he will be here all summer, which can only be good news. My first thought was how he could do the job at a distance, but his presence will be an asset.
Houghton has a big job and for me his first task is to look at a senior core of players who have simply not delivered, for whatever reasons, as well as ensuring that his better young players are on contracts appropriate to their talent.
I am always honest, so will say that for what we are reportedly paying them, we are not getting value for money from Rampaul, Viljoen and Wilson. Yet all are contracted for at least one, in Rampaul's case two more summers. Is coming to an agreement and paying them up an option? Only the CEO knows the answer to that, but if we go down that route there needs to be money for cheaper but perhaps more effective replacements.
There are good players out there and the identification of those players will be part of John Wright's role. Such players as Luis Reece and Ryan Higgins at Gloucestershire are prime examples of what can be done with a fresh environment. I am not averse to a Kolpak signing per se, and look at players such as Kuhn, Morkel, Harmer, Wiese, Ingram, Ackermann and Kleinveldt for prime examples of what they can do.
For whatever reasons ours haven't done that, at least not consistently.
It may be that we have to accept next season as the start of the process, as Houghton will likely identify players he doesn't think are good enough, but cannot afford to move on. I will be impressed and astonished if he can start that process this winter, but either way it promises to be an interesting one.
The summer has not been a shambles. There have been sufficient pointers for the future from some players to be encouraged. A top three of Godleman, Reece and Madsen is something to build around. I would offer a deserved further year to Tony Palladino, possibly with a coaching remit and hope that Duanne Olivier might consider a Kolpak role, given his distance from the South African national set up.
The concern is that after that there is no one whose sustained performances this year have suggested they have a long-term role to play, though Matt Critchley and Hamidullah Qadri can only improve with greater experience. I still rate Alex Hughes as a player, but despite his fine bowling in the T20 he has scored nowhere near the runs required for a number four and at 27 this month can no longer be considered a junior.
Having said all that, I look forward to your responses.
In closing, welcome back to Derbyshire Dave.
I hope your stay is a long and memorable one, for all the right reasons.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)