Saturday, 12 September 2026

Weekend thoughts

Continuing the good vibes of yesterday's win over Kent, Nye Donald hit an eight-ball 31 for England Lions as they strolled to a win over their Sri Lankan counterparts last night. They chased down a modest target of 118 to win in less than eight overs - a one-sided game following on from the series of the England senior side against Pakistan. 

I hope that there is more of that from Nye when the full series starts - and more, because we all know how destructive he can be in his best form.

But enough of international cricket - there are plenty of places writing about that. I am sure that we all awoke today, happy with the memory of an excellent 4-day win over Kent at Derby. It was another great advert for the red ball game and it remains my favourite form of cricket. Nothing matches the ebb and flow of the long form and while it can happen in shorter formats, there is so much to enjoy in 4-day cricket, as there was in 3-day, when it was played.

It again reinforced that for all of their inconsistency, Derbyshire are not too far from having a good side. They need better luck with injuries and any chance of improved fortunes in 2027 depends on having a full complement of bowlers to work with. We have been remarkably fortunate this year that Ben Aitchison has been able to bowl all summer, but no player can expect that every year. Injuries are a part of professional sport, especially among seam bowlers. I doubt there are many of them play through the season without aches, pains and niggles, because the whole mechanical process of bowling doesn't sit well with how bodies are supposed to move. I somehow doubt that cavemen threw their spears 120 times a day and certainly not off a long run up...

Moving on, I had a look at the averages this morning. Brett Randell, Rory Haydon and Ben all have their wickets under 23 runs each, while Martin Andersson has 21 at 28, as well as a batting average of 45. These are good statistics and each can be proud of their summers. 

For next season, as a bare minimum, Derbyshire need a top overseas bat. I said so in my latest interview with James Sadler of North Derbyshire Radio last night and strengthening the middle order is crucial. At least for next year, any two from three of Reece, Came and Naeem should serve us well at the top, but it depends on who becomes available. There is also the matter of replacing Wayne Madsen, almost certainly for 2028, but if someone came onto the market now then it would make sense to act.

In my lengthy bag of correspondence, I have been asked if I would take back Shan Masood, should he be available. Yes, although at 37 he perhaps isn't now at his prime. He has struggled in the series against England, but that attack is considerably stronger than anything he would face in division two next year. The relegation battle in division one is very tight, but none of the likely sides to drop carries remotely the threat that Durham did this year. 

The other issue, as we have seen with Mohammad Abbas this year, is the Pakistan penchant for short notice tours. Masood is currently their captain and it is important that whoever comes in is available for most of the summer. There may be wholesale changes after this awful tour that they have endured, but I'm sure that those at Derby will be carefully monitoring the situation, as they will be of several other options.

Another player who will doubtless interest counties for 2027 will be Leus du Plooy. He has decided to play for his native South Africa and has left his role at Middlesex. While I'm sure they would have him back as an overseas player, it may be that the debacle regarding the failure to register him to play in that role for the remainder of the summer is a disincentive. They don't seem awfully well organised down there, but I am sure that Leus will not lack suitors for 2027, given his record in the county game. 

Would he consider Derbyshire? Why not, although as we know money talks and the number of proven quality overseas players diminishes by the year. Like Masood, Leus may find himself involved in South Africa tours at full or A level and it prevents his playing in England next year, or for many seasons in the future. 

I am sure that Mickey Arthur and the cricket committee are working already on options for 2027. It must be difficult, because you can make all the plans and then find a later-organised tour throws them into disarray, much as happened with Mohammad Abbas. You can't wait and see, either, because otherwise you are searching in an even more limited marketplace.

Picking up a player who goes under the radar is very satisfying, however. Brett Randell is a case in point and at 31 he perhaps didn't expect another opportunity in county cricket, after a short stint previously at Somerset. Yet opportunity knocked, as Hughie Green used to say and he has snatched that opportunity with both hands. 

I will be honest, I only really knew him from the five wickets in five balls last winter, but he has impressed me, not just with his excellent bowling, but his overall attitude. He dives around in the field, contributes with the bat and looks the kind of bloke you are glad to have on your side. 

The acid test for any overseas player is the simple question - would you have him back? Most certainly, in the case of Brett, the answer is yes. But we must hope for an uninterrupted season of Abbas at his best in 2027. If he showed anything like his form in the Test matches, he should dominate the division.

One thing that has come out of the recent fixtures, however, is that it is unrealistic, given how the county schedule runs at present, to play two specialist spinners on a regular basis.

Historically, spin bowlers came into their own in July and August. The sun shone on used pitches, dried them out and the strength in that sun made the twirlers stride out with a spring in their step, their fingers twitching to get going. It is when they took the bulk of their wickets and earned their contract for the following year.

Dampness is coming back into September pitches and the sun isn't strong enough to dry it out. While it is always preferable to have a spinner in the side, two is a luxury that few can afford, unless one is also handy with the bat. 

If you have someone like Liam Dawson, James Coles or Matt Critchley in your side it is fine, as you know, they will contribute their weight of runs. But even someone as talented as Simon Harmer has only 34 wickets at 34 this year and Rehan Ahmed, oft-cited as Bashir's likely England replacement, has 18 wickets at 40.

Coles has 25 wickets at 29 but averages 35 with the bat, while Dawson has just 7 wickets at 53 and has struggled with the bat for once. Meanwhile Critchley has 19 wickets at 30, but also averages 50 with the bat, which isn't the worst of seasons.

Jack Morley can handle a bat as he has shown, but nor is he by some distance a genuine all-rounder. I am sure that Derbyshire will be hoping Shoaib Bashir retains his England central contract, because otherwise one of them will be sitting on the sidelines a lot. Besides which, the county would need to pick up the cost of his contract, which would certainly affect any ability to improve the squad this winter. 

Anyway, Mohammad Abbas, according to Mickey Arthur, is available for the next game, against Northamptonshire, starting on Tuesday. Logically two spinners WILL play there, because the pitches at Wantage Road always encourage spin. I remember Edwin Smith telling me the story of arriving at Northampton in the 1950s to find what looked like a very unusual green top. On closer inspection it turned out to be grass cuttings, laid on top of the traditional dry, sandy pitch! 

Yuzi Chahal will be waiting for his opportunity this week, as will Calvin Harrison. With Abbas, Morley and Bashir likely to be at 9-11, we must only hope that Ben Aitchison channels his inner Sobers at eight..

It may be that the final game, at Worcester, sees both Abbas and Brett Randell play, alongside Aitchison. While it will be the last game of the summer, that is a mouth-watering prospect...

Anyway, enjoy your weekend. Eight days of cricket to go before the long and pesky winter...hopefully they give us plenty of reasons to be cheerful.

PS in that interview link above, I am on at 23.30.

18 comments:

  1. I'd stick with Randell over Abbas for the next game. Has looked far more interested and far more effective. Would be looking to do the same next season as well

    Abbas has 11 wickets at 40.5. Randall 15 at 19 in 2 less games.

    For next season Aitchison, Haydon and Randell with Andersson as the all rounder is a very serious attack. Frankly the rest of the bowlers on the books aren't up to it. Moore deserves time but would rather see Stewart or Green over the rest of the current bunch who are injury prone and ineffective even when fit and have all now proven so over a long period.

    Hopefully Reece has another season in him because I'm not convinced much in Came or Montgomery offering much consistency at the top and sadly Madsen is shot to pieces. Mad to not be giving Wagstaff a shot opening in these remaining dead rubbers after his form in the seconds this season. Likewise Basra.

    MA continues to bungle and the win over Kent doesn't paper over these cracks for me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you, but you can't just rip up a contract. Not if you expect players to sign for you in the future, perhaps with the same agent.

      It might be that the NOC from New Zealand limits what Randell plays and that he has to get the game off. Not unusual for that to happen so players aren't overworked.

      I suspect that next season will see a lot of changes for 2028.

      That Mitch hasn't been selected tells a story, don't you think?

      Delete
    2. Abbas looked like he wasn't fussed about playing for us, could be an option to agree a mutual early release at part of the value of the contract or to release early if other counties are interested. We should explore all options as he's been woeful.

      Wouldn't surprise me if that's already in the offing and he magically plays very well in the remaining games to put himself in the shop window.

      It also wouldn't surprise me to see D1 Counties looking to buy out Aitchison's contract early and the club will undoubtedly cash in if so as they have little on field ambition. Little reason for him to hang around either if he has the chance to earn much more plus go and win things and threaten England selectors. He's certainly good enough to play at the very top of the English game. If this happens we can't afford to carry Abbas for another season.

      And I don't think Wagstaff's exclusion tells us anything because MA has proven clueless when it comes to assessing player quality and potential. A player of undoubted promise whom MA has messed around appallingly over the last few years. The two 50s in his debut season were excellent knocks, it was quite clear we had a serious potential opener on our hands and he was rewarded with being dropped for the remaining dead rubber games that season and we've seen him sparingly since. He started the season in roaring form for the seconds and hasn't had a look in over a top order who mostly average mid 20s or less. And now we'll never know if could do a job for us up top. Frankly it's pretty clear that Came can't do it consistently, Reece is again and can see no reason not to give Wagstaff the remaining four innings of the season to play for a deal (too little but better than nothing).

      Delete
    3. Counties don’t like going down the route of buying out contracts they tend to wait until the June date to play the market that way. It just over inflates the salary for the first year and budgets are usually tight. It’s cricket not football. Once again Abbas has just been named man of the series, we have probably got him for another year let’s hope he brings some of that form to us.

      Delete
    4. I wouldn't play both Bashir and Morley in the next two games. If Chappell is fit, I'd bring him in, as he is more of an all-rounder than Aitchison, so far. Batting at eight is too high for Aitchison, So far, Randell looks great. I wouldn't replace him with Abbas, but Mickey probably will. I think Randell is more hungry to make a mark than Abbas, who , with respect, has seen it all and done it all.

      Delete
    5. Am I missing something in this debate about whether to play Randell or Abbas for the next two games?--because, with Jewell having gone home, surely the answer is that you play both of them. Aitchison, Randell, Abbas, Bashir as the specialist bowlers.

      And next season there isn't a question: Abbas is under contract as an overseas player until or unless the FTP (not yet formulated for next season) creates a period where he's unavailable because he's playing for Pakistan. (Of course, that also seems to depend on the considerable capriciousness of Aaqib Javed, so anything could happen there!) As PF says, you don't start arbitrarily ripping up contracts...unless you want your contracted players to start doing the same to you!

      Dave

      Delete
    6. Unfortunately Wagstaff's form has fallen off a cliff. Second successive 'first baller' in league cricket yesterday.

      Treated poorly by MA. I've always felt he's just not quite good enough - just my opinion - but not given sufficient opportunity. Got injured prior to the One Day Cup last season too. The signs don't look good for his retention..

      Delete
    7. Dave: re Randell, my understanding is that his NOC from New Zealand limits the cricket he plays to protect his workload. So he will likely miss the next game but be available for the last.

      Increasingly common for overseas bowlers to have such limitations in place, normally stopping them playing 3 straight 4 day games, especially ahead of the domestic season, as it is here

      Delete
  2. I must be missing something, as I think Abbas has bowled well for Derbyshire. He was excellent at Queen's Park and there have numerous catches put down off his bowling. Economical throughout this season, despite the lack of wickets. Maybe just me? We've had far worse than Abbas, in my opinion. Kris

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh there have been many worse, Kris. But in terms of expectation and results, a disappointment. Early season all the bowlers suffered with drops and I do think his control helped Aitchison and Haydon. But he didn't do to division 2 sides what he did to England. Which is surely frustrating?

      Delete
    2. A proven international bowler who has previously ripped up division 1. He has been poor value for us, no question. Randell meanwhile....

      Delete
    3. Thanks Anon (please add a name!) We are the only club where he has failed and I would like to think that his professionalism, should he be able to take up year two of his contract, might make him want to remedy that next year

      Delete
    4. Apologies, forgot to add my name! I was replying to Kris, I don't doubt he will be keen to perform next year, but there is no doubt that he has been very much below par so far. Yes, typical it's only us!!

      Delete
  3. Re availability for overseas tours:

    --for Abbas (or Masood): as I posted under the last piece, none of the tours which Abbas was called up for were organised (or published in the FTP) later than 2022. The Bangladesh tour was moved by a month or so, but it would still have taken Abbas out of the same number of games in the same block of matches. The fickleness of the Pakistan selectors might sometimes be a problem (although of course this can cut both ways!); short notice tours rarely are, and pretty much none of those tours are red-ball ones anyway.

    --for du Plooy: I would be surprised if the registration issue has any bearing at all on du Plooy's apparently very warm relationship with Middlesex. From the timeline of events, Middlesex simply couldn't have registered him as an overseas player in time, because they hadn't been informed by the ECB that they had to, and there was no logical reason to suppose that they had to given that du Plooy hadn't said anything about an intention to change status for the 2026 season. It doesn't appear to be anything to do with administrative incompetence by Middx.

    As I've already posted, I would offer him an all-format contract and the captaincy. But I'd be surprised if he said yes. The tone of the announcement of his leaving Middx seemed warm on both sides, yet it was clear that he wasn't taking up Middx's offer of an overseas slot for next year. Of course, there may be more to it than meets the eye, but I'd be surprised if he plays for any county next season--not that that's a reason not to try!

    Dave

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The issue with Abbas, Dave, was the administration change. It was always likely that he would play in England, but it was felt unlikely he would go to Bangladesh and the Caribbean under that regime. The change meant he was picked up for all of them.

      Du Plooy? I can't think of many counties who wouldn't want him, but it depends on his commitments with South Africa and indeed if he wants to play in this country. Middlesex might want him, then again he might want to play somewhere less expensive to live than London. It will be interesting to see how that plays out, but certainly the offer of captaincy would be a carrot to dangle, assuming that Derbyshire are not already looking - or are committed - elsewhere

      Delete
    2. Dave not sure the info you have but the 6th September registration date seems fairly clear and something all counties would and should have been aware of. At best its a communication issue between the player and county at worse its careless.
      Quoted from ESPN-"Middlesex have taken legal advice in a bid to make captain Leus du Plooy available for the rest of the season after an embarrassing administrative error inadvertently jeopardised his status as a local player.

      Du Plooy, 31, has played as a local player in county cricket since 2019 thanks to his Hungarian passport. He had previously expressed his desire to play for England but recently informed the club that he intends to recommit to his native South Africa. He will be eligible to play for them immediately under ICC regulations and will join Titans for the upcoming domestic season.Du Plooy was under contract with Middlesex for 2027, but the club announced on Saturday morning that he would leave them at the end of this summer after his decision to recommit to South Africa, which would have forced them to re-register him as an overseas player for the final year of his deal and had the potential to limit his availability.

      However, Middlesex were unaware until Monday morning that, under ECB regulations, du Plooy's declaration automatically rendered him ineligible to continue playing as a local player for the rest of the county season. While they had a vacant spot in their squad for an overseas player, they did not realise their mistake until after Sunday's deadline to register one.

      The ECB's ruling means that du Plooy will not be available to play in next Sunday's Metro Bank Cup final - Middlesex's first List A final since 1990 - against Leicestershire at Trent Bridge. He has not featured in the competition this season due to his involvement in the Hundred, though would have been eligible but for Middlesex's error.

      Du Plooy travelled to Chester-le-Street on Monday as the club sought a resolution with the ECB but was left out of their playing XI to face Durham in the County Championship, with Max Holden replacing him as captain. Middlesex sit fourth in Division Two but their promotion hopes are slim, even after bowling Durham out for 252 on Tuesday.

      Alan Coleman, Middlesex's director of cricket, said that the club had sought legal advice and were working with the Professional Cricketers' Association in an attempt to overturn the ECB's decision on du Plooy's availability. "We will continue to position this and discuss this with the ECB and hope for a positive resolution," he said."
      Lets face it its not surprising this happened with all that goes off at Middlesex at the moment. The same Director of cricket is also on his way at the end of the season. It's a very basic error as there are similar dates in place for loans etc. Its debatable whether Middlesex can afford an overseas player next season plus has been quoted his availability at this stage is unknown due to whether he gets his wish to play for SA at 31.He has probably been given some encouragement for him to take this decision

      The rule as is in place
      The final date an overseas cricketer can be registered for an English county cricket season is early September. For the 2026 season, the official England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) deadline was Sunday, 6 September 2026. [1] (https://www.middlesexccc.com/news/2026/09/leus-du-plooy-unable-to-play-for-remainder-of-2026-season)This deadline is strictly enforced; any player who is not registered by this date—including existing local players whose status suddenly changes to "overseas" due to declarations of international intent—cannot be registered or selected for the remainder of that season. [1] (https://www.theherald.co.za/sport/2026-09-09-captain-du-plooy-ineligible-for-middlesex-over-sa-declaration/), [2] (https://www.middlesexccc.com/news/2026/09/leus-du-plooy-unable-to-play-for-remainder-of-2026-season)

      Jason

      Delete
    3. Thanks Jason, full and appreciated response!

      Delete

Please remember to add your name. Avoid personal comment at all times. Thanks!