It's difficult of course. The only person whose opinion really matters is Mickey Arthur. He knows the mental and physical state of all the players, as well as the form they have shown in the nets. None of us do.
Players are no different to you and I. They will have things going on in their lives, a personal problem, a health issue, a challenge with a loved one. All of these will mitigate against their involvement, or being at their best. Football fans have only to look at the current absence of Jacob Zetterstrom from the Derby County side, an unspecified - and it would seem as yet undiagnosed - illness is preventing him from playing.
Yet assuming full fitness and good form of the entire squad, this would be the eleven that I would put onto the field:
Caleb Jewell
Harry Came
Matt Montgomery
Wayne Madsen
Brooke Guest
Luis Reece
Martin Andersson
Zak Chappell
Ben Aitchison
Mohammad Abbas
Shoaib Bashir
The strength of the squad for 2026 is highlighted by the fact that there are several strong exclusions in that side. There would be those who argue for Nye Donald to open and give us a fast start, but I am keeping his powder dry for now. Martin Andersson gets the nod ahead of Anuj Dal, because of his three centuries last year. With four good seamers in the side the stronger batter (on most recent form) gets the place. Martin should also be fit to do more bowling this year, if needed. With four strong seamers, do you really need a fifth? A counter argument could be playing Donald at seven, or even Mitch Wagstaff, who would give you a third spinner. Amrit Basra and Rory Haydon will be rotated in and the performances of both are eagerly awaited.
Yet Arthur recently said that Andersson has the talent to play for England and it would be silly to omit him after that assertion.
Shoaib Bashir will get the nod over Jack Morley. The latter did nothing wrong and produced some telling spells last year, but he needs to bide his time and produce the figures in second team cricket to justify his elevation.
Shoaib will be first choice and will get plenty of cricket, which is what he needs. There are a lot of players in sport who need to feel that they belong at a club. For what it is worth, I think Derbyshire is the perfect fit for the England spinner.
I also hope that his involvement in the eleven, alongside Mohammad Abbas, sees an increase in support from the local ethnic community, which would be welcome.
We don't have long to wait now and I'm sure everyone is excited to see how Mohammad Abbas will do in Derbyshire colours. He was 36 this week, the same age that Eddie Barlow was when he came to the county. Given his style of bowling, I don't think the number matters. He took 57 wickets in ten first-class matches in Pakistan this winter and while acknowledging that the standard may not always be the same, that still takes some doing. He will be raring to go on his apparently incentivised contract and that can only be to everyone's benefit.
Once he settles, works out his preferred end and gets into his rhythm, I have every confidence that he will lead the attack with considerable style and panache.
Watch this space.
Of course, I'm now equally interested to see if you agree, or where you might tweak the side for that opening match.
Over to you!
I know one thing Steve our 2nd XL will be worth a watch this season......without doubt our strongest squad for a long,long time....can't wait !!! Cheers Gary
ReplyDeleteThis would be mine. No spinner required at Derby in April for me, Montgomery to bowl, if needed. Donald to give impetus at the top. Dal bowls well at Derby, so I give him the nod over Andersson. Guest to bat in the "traditional" keeper slot of 7.
ReplyDeleteJewell
Donald
Came
Madsen
Montgomery
Reece
Guest
Dal
Chappell
Aitchison
Abbas
Thanks Anon..could you remember to add a name please?
DeleteCan't argue with that lineup. Likely to be one or two 'niggles' pre season that might rule out one or two, but we have options as you've listed.
ReplyDeleteI'm intrigued to see how Basra does. Looks a real talent to me. I have a feeling MA will be keen to get him involved. Came deserves his chance, but he may come under pressure for his place if he doesn't start the season well. Perhaps then Reece to open (I know, workload!) with Basra slotting in to the middle order.
No doubt a few will argue for Donald, but he wouldn't currently be in my first choice XI.
[PJS]
ReplyDeleteI think MA would be hoping to start with your selection but I would teak it a little, swapping Andersson & Reece around in the batting line up.
No one has mentioned Harry Moore, do we know if he is fit and available?
Worcesterrams makes a great point about the 2nd XI. Drawn from the remaining 'squad':
Donald
Wagstaff
Bin-Naeem
Basra
Whiteley
Dal
Moore
Hawkins
Haydon
Potts
Morley
I don't think they will rush Harry, so I would be surprised if he was in the the early sides.
DeleteYour second team looks very impressive! Let's not forget that they will want to give plenty of opportunity to Rohan Vallabhaneni and Matt Stewart too, at the very least. Both must be in with a shout of a place on the staff in 2027. There are others who could be equally deserving of opportunity
Is Luis Reece fit to start the season? I understand he was having some work done to address a long term knee problem over the winter. Let's all hope this went well.
DeleteIs Madsen going to be 100% fit? I’m not sure a specialist spinner will be needed, if not I would give Haydon a place. We should always pick the 4 bowlers most likely to bowl the opposition out., 1 all rounder & our 5 best batsmen. I like the look of your team subject to Madsens fitness & the need for spin
ReplyDeleteMarkB
I'd go with the same team as you, Peakfan, though perhaps with Reece coming in ahead of Guest. I agree with Jasper about Harry Came. He is an experienced player now and he needs to be able to convert sound starts into bigger scores more regularly.
ReplyDeleteI would go with your starting X1. Great to have such competition for starting places. Could this be our year? Grant from Telford.
ReplyDeleteWould like a bit more batting depth, drop down to 5 bowlers either Aitchison or Chappell (open with Reece and Abbas) miss out to allow Donald to open and put Came at 3 (gives more protection from an early wicket). Also im very fluid about the order of reece, brooke and andersson
ReplyDeleteChappell is one of our best bowlers and can bat. Him coming in at 8 is fine for me. Grant from Telford
DeleteI just think that first change attack a very strong one. Especially with Haydon and Moore outside the eleven, as well as Brown and Potts.
DeleteLike Grant I consider him an all rounder and Ben can certainly bat, at nine.
Caleb Jewell woefully out of form in Oz. That needs to change if we're going to get off to a decent start.
ReplyDeleteForm is temporary etc.... 🤞
DeleteYeah, I don't think his Aussie average close to what he did here last year. Then again, Michael di Venuto scored many more runs here than in Australia, so maybe English tracks suit him? We will doubtless find out soon enough, but all players go through bad trots at some point
DeleteI think that the tracks he's been playing on in Oz have not been as friendly to batters as we normally get at Derby.
ReplyDeleteAnyway regardless of which 11 we pick I am in danger of suffering from mild optimism which for me is somewhat rare.
You can definitely see the strength in depth and this could be key to our success.
ReplyDeleteI do think the batting maybe the weakness this year. We had very solid season last year from Madsen and Jewell. The winter been tough for both them in different ways. I think early season the batting will be key. I I would like to see Reece open and Came number 3.
Hope you kept well steve through the winter. I will look forward for reading blog.
A mistake to leave out Donald. He was underused in the Championship last year.
ReplyDelete